Walsh Sophie D, Blass David, Bensimon-Braverman Meital, Barak Lee Topaz, Delayahu Yael
Department of Criminology, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, 52900, Israel,
J Immigr Minor Health. 2014 Dec;16(6):1045-54. doi: 10.1007/s10903-014-9982-1.
Two studies were conducted among patients in a male dual diagnosis (severe mental illness [SMI] with substance use) ward. The research examined the following questions: (1) Do immigrant and non-immigrant dual diagnosis patients exhibit similar or different socio-demographic, clinical and criminological characteristics? (2) What are the implications for treatment of immigrant (and non-immigrant) patients? Study one analyzed computerized hospital records of 413 male patients; Study two examined patient files of a subgroup of 141 (70 immigrant) male patients. Alongside similarities, non-immigrant patients reported higher numbers of repeat and involuntary hospitalizations and more drug use while immigrants showed longer hospitalizations, more suicide attempts, more violent suicide attempts, more violent offenses and more alcohol use. Among non-immigrants significant relationships were found between severity of SMI and crime/violence while among immigrants a significant relationship was found between suicidality and crime/violence. Implications for treatment include need for awareness of suicide risk among immigrant dual-diagnosis patients and an understanding of the differential relationship with crime/violence for the two populations.
在一个收治男性双重诊断(患有严重精神疾病[SMI]且有药物使用问题)患者的病房中开展了两项研究。该研究探讨了以下问题:(1)移民和非移民双重诊断患者在社会人口学、临床和犯罪学特征方面表现相似还是不同?(2)对移民(和非移民)患者的治疗有何影响?研究一分析了413名男性患者的计算机化医院记录;研究二检查了141名(70名移民)男性患者亚组的病历。除了相似之处外,非移民患者的重复和非自愿住院次数更多,药物使用更多,而移民的住院时间更长,自杀未遂次数更多,暴力自杀未遂次数更多,暴力犯罪更多,酒精使用更多。在非移民患者中,发现SMI严重程度与犯罪/暴力之间存在显著关系,而在移民患者中,发现自杀倾向与犯罪/暴力之间存在显著关系。治疗方面的影响包括需要意识到移民双重诊断患者的自杀风险,以及理解这两类人群与犯罪/暴力之间的不同关系。