Division of Infertility and Reproductive Endocrinology, University of Pennsylvania Medical School, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Fertil Steril. 2010 Feb;93(3):681-90. doi: 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2009.10.047. Epub 2009 Nov 25.
To review variations in specific reproductive health outcomes by race and ethnicity. A growing number of reports have explored potential gaps in the quality of reproductive health and healthcare across racial and ethnic groups. Diverse results from numerous investigations have made it challenging for practitioners to confirm the significance of these disparities.
METHOD(S): Three specific areas of the reproductive life cycle were examined: pubertal onset, outcomes from treatment with assisted reproductive technologies (ART), and the menopausal transition. These areas were selected as they encompass a continuum of events across the reproductive life span of women. Outcomes were compared in black, white, Asian, and Hispanic women. Medline searches querying on keywords puberty, IVF, ART, menopause, menopausal symptoms, racial disparity, race, Asian, Japanese, Chinese, African American, black, Hispanic, and Latino were performed to isolate relevant publications for review.
RESULT(S): Differences across race and ethnicity were noted in each clinical endpoint. The most notable findings included earlier puberty in blacks and Hispanics compared with whites, significantly lower live birth rates after ART in all racial and ethnic groups compared with whites, and differences in perimenopausal symptomatology and possibly timing in various racial/ethnic groups compared with whites. Additional research is needed to completely unravel the full significance and basic underpinnings of these disparities. Some of the limitations of the current state of the literature in drawing conclusions about the independent effect of race/ethnicity on reproductive disparities include small samples sizes in some studies, inconsistencies in the characterization of racial/ethnic groups, and incomplete control of potential confounding.
CONCLUSION(S): Race and ethnicity appear to be important correlates of outcomes from the initiation of reproduction functioning through to its conclusion. The ultimate goal of identifying racial disparities in reproduction is to isolate the basic determinants of disparities and formulate strategies to improve outcomes for women at risk. The differences demonstrated in this review of the literature could represent environmental, sociocultural, and/or genetic correlates of race that influence these important milestones.
综述种族和民族差异对特定生殖健康结果的影响。越来越多的报告探讨了不同种族和民族群体在生殖健康和医疗保健质量方面可能存在的差距。大量研究得出的结果不一,使得从业者难以确定这些差异的重要性。
本研究检查了生殖生命周期的三个特定领域:青春期开始、辅助生殖技术(ART)治疗的结果以及绝经过渡。选择这些领域是因为它们涵盖了女性生殖生命周期中一系列事件。比较了黑人、白人、亚洲人和西班牙裔女性的结果。通过关键词“青春期”、“试管婴儿”、“ART”、“绝经”、“绝经症状”、“种族差异”、“种族”、“亚洲”、“日本”、“中国”、“非裔美国人”、“黑人”、“西班牙裔”和“拉丁裔”在 Medline 上进行搜索,以分离出相关的出版物进行审查。
在每个临床终点,种族和民族之间都存在差异。最显著的发现包括黑人与白人相比青春期更早,所有种族和民族群体的 ART 后活产率明显低于白人,以及绝经前症状学和某些种族/民族群体与白人相比可能存在的时间差异。需要进一步研究以完全揭示这些差异的全部意义和基本基础。目前有关种族/民族对生殖差异的独立影响的文献结论存在一些局限性,包括一些研究中样本量小、种族/民族群体特征不一致以及潜在混杂因素控制不完整。
种族和民族似乎是生殖功能开始到结束的结果的重要相关因素。确定生殖方面的种族差异的最终目标是确定差异的基本决定因素,并制定策略来改善处于危险中的妇女的结果。本研究对文献的回顾中显示的差异可能代表影响这些重要里程碑的环境、社会文化和/或遗传相关因素。