Centre for Tobacco Control Research, University of Stirling and The Open University, Stirling, UK.
Br J Cancer. 2009 Dec 3;101 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):S73-9. doi: 10.1038/sj.bjc.6605395.
Scotland has a high incidence of mouth cancer, but public awareness and knowledge are low compared with other cancers. The West of Scotland Cancer Awareness Project sought to increase public awareness and knowledge of mouth cancer and to encourage early detection of symptoms among an at-risk population of people aged over 40 years from lower socio-economic groups using a mass media approach. The media campaign aimed to increase people's feelings of personal risk, while also enhancing feelings of efficacy and control. To achieve this, a testimonial approach (using real people to tell their own stories) was adopted.
Campaign impact and reach was assessed using in-home interviews with a representative sample of the target population in both the campaign area and controls outside of the target area. Surveys were conducted at three stages: at baseline before the campaign was launched, and at 7 and 12 months thereafter.
Awareness of media coverage was higher at both follow-up points in the intervention area than in the control area, the differences largely being accounted for by television advertising. The campaign had a short-term, but not a long-term impact on awareness of the disease and intention to respond to the symptoms targeted by the campaign. Awareness of two of the symptoms featured in the campaign (ulcers and lumps) increased, post-campaign, among the intervention group.
While the study provides evidence for the effectiveness of the self-referral model, further work is needed to assess its ability to build public capacity to respond appropriately to symptoms and to compare the cost-effectiveness of a mass media approach against alternative communication approaches and more conventional mass screening.
苏格兰的口腔癌发病率很高,但与其他癌症相比,公众的意识和知识水平较低。苏格兰西部癌症宣传项目旨在通过大众媒体的方式,提高高危人群(年龄在 40 岁以上、社会经济地位较低的人群)对口腔癌的认识和知识,并鼓励他们及早发现症状。该媒体活动旨在提高人们的个人风险感,同时增强他们的效能感和控制感。为了实现这一目标,采用了证言法(使用真实的人讲述自己的故事)。
通过对目标人群在宣传活动地区和非目标地区的代表性样本进行入户访谈,评估了宣传活动的影响和覆盖范围。在三个阶段进行了调查:在宣传活动开始前的基线阶段,以及之后的 7 个月和 12 个月。
在干预地区,无论是在随访的哪个时间点,对媒体报道的认识都高于对照组,这种差异主要归因于电视广告。该活动对疾病的认识和对宣传活动所针对症状的反应意愿只有短期影响,而没有长期影响。在干预组中,宣传活动后,对两个症状(溃疡和肿块)的认识有所提高。
虽然该研究为自我推荐模型的有效性提供了证据,但还需要进一步研究来评估其建立公众适当应对症状的能力,并比较大众媒体方法与替代沟通方法和更传统的大众筛查方法的成本效益。