Drug Policy Modelling Program, National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia.
Int J Drug Policy. 2010 Jul;21(4):265-70. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2009.11.002. Epub 2009 Dec 14.
The application of regulatory theory to the problem of illicit drugs has generally been thought about only in terms of 'command and control'. The international treaties governing global illicit drug control and the use of law enforcement to dissuade and punish offenders have been primary strategies. In this paper I explore the application of other aspects of regulatory theory to illicit drugs-primarily self-regulation and market regulation. There has been an overreliance on strategies from the top of the regulatory pyramid. Two other regulatory strategies--self-regulation and market regulation--can be applied to illicit drugs. Self-regulation, driven by the proactive support of consumer groups may reduce drug-related harms. Market strategies such as pill-testing can change consumer preferences and encourage alternate seller behaviour. Regulatory theory is also concerned with partnerships between the state and third parties: strategies in these areas include partnerships between police and pharmacies regarding sale of potential precursor chemicals. Regulatory theory and practice is a rich and well-developed field in the social sciences. I argue that governments should consider the full array of regulatory strategies. Using regulatory theory provides a rationale and justification to strategies that are currently at the whim of politics, such as funding for user groups. The greater application of regulatory approaches may produce more flexible and structured illicit drug policies.
管制理论在非法药物问题上的应用,通常只被认为是“命令与控制”。管理全球非法药物管制和利用执法手段劝阻和惩罚违法者的国际条约一直是主要战略。在本文中,我探讨了管制理论在非法药物方面的其他应用,主要是自我管制和市场管制。人们过分依赖于管制金字塔顶端的战略。另外两种管制策略——自我管制和市场管制——可以应用于非法药物。在消费者群体的积极支持下,自我管制可能会减少与药物有关的危害。诸如药丸测试等市场策略可以改变消费者的偏好,并鼓励替代卖家的行为。管制理论还涉及国家与第三方之间的伙伴关系:这些领域的战略包括警察与药店之间关于潜在前体化学品销售的伙伴关系。管制理论和实践在社会科学领域是一个丰富和发达的领域。我认为政府应该考虑各种管制策略。使用管制理论为目前受政治影响的策略提供了合理依据和正当理由,例如为用户群体提供资金。更广泛地应用管制方法可能会产生更灵活和结构化的非法药物政策。