Morinomiya University of Medical Sciences, 1-26-16, Nankokita, Suminoe, Osaka 559-8611, Japan.
Int J Psychophysiol. 2010 Mar;75(3):268-76. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2009.12.008. Epub 2009 Dec 16.
The present study examined selected autonomic and cardio-respiratory responses of nine elite pianists during solo performances of the same single musical piece. The subjects performed the piece with and without self-perceived emotional expression, and with and without free ancillary body movements during expressive performance. Autonomic nervous system and cardio-respiratory parameters were continuously monitored during all experimental conditions. These parameters were heart rate (HR), sweating rate, the root mean square of successive difference (RMSSD) of heart rate variability and respiratory measurements such as oxygen consumption (VO(2)), minute ventilation, tidal volume and respiratory rate. Kinematics of the trunk and arms were recorded during all conditions. The subjects also provided subjective rating of the emotions that they experienced during their performances for each experimental condition. Analysis revealed that expressive performance clearly produced higher levels of valence and arousal than the non-expressive condition. This observation is consistent with current embodiment theory. The expressive condition also had significantly higher levels of HR, sweating rate, minute ventilation, and tidal volume, and lower levels of RMSSD and respiratory rate than the non-expressive condition. No difference was found for VO(2) between these conditions. The expressive condition with ancillary body movements did not significantly differentiate any of the physiological measures except for respiratory rate from those observed without such body movements. These findings suggested that expressive musical performance could modulate the emotion-related autonomic and cardio-respiratory responses that are independent of the effect of physiological load due to expressive ancillary body movements in playing the selected music on the piano.
本研究考察了 9 位杰出钢琴家在演奏同一首乐曲时自主神经和心肺反应的选择。研究对象在有和没有自我感知的情感表达、有和没有自由辅助身体运动的情况下进行表现性演奏。在所有实验条件下,连续监测自主神经系统和心肺参数。这些参数包括心率(HR)、出汗率、心率变异性的均方根差(RMSSD)和呼吸测量,如耗氧量(VO2)、分钟通气量、潮气量和呼吸频率。在所有条件下,还记录了躯干和手臂的运动学。研究对象还为每个实验条件下他们在演奏中体验到的情绪提供了主观评价。分析表明,表现性演奏明显产生了比非表现性条件更高的情感价值和唤醒度。这一观察结果与当前的体现理论一致。表现性条件下的 HR、出汗率、分钟通气量和潮气量明显高于非表现性条件,RMSSD 和呼吸频率明显低于非表现性条件。两种条件下的 VO2 没有差异。有辅助身体运动的表现性条件除了呼吸频率外,与没有这种身体运动的条件相比,对任何生理测量都没有显著差异。这些发现表明,表现性音乐演奏可以调节与情感相关的自主神经和心肺反应,这些反应独立于因演奏所选音乐时的表达性辅助身体运动而产生的生理负荷的影响。