Department of Psychological Medicine and Neurology, Cardiff University, University Hospital of Wales, Heath Park, Cardiff, UK.
Br J Psychiatry. 2010 Jan;196(1):69-74. doi: 10.1192/bjp.bp.109.066266.
How best to plan and provide psychosocial care following disasters remains keenly debated.
To develop evidence-informed post-disaster psychosocial management guidelines.
A three-round web-based Delphi process was conducted. One hundred and six experts rated the importance of statements generated from existing evidence using a one to nine scale. Participants reassessed their original scores in the light of others' responses in the subsequent rounds.
A total of 80 (72%) of 111 statements achieved consensus for inclusion. The statement 'all responses should provide access to pharmacological assessment and management' did not achieve consensus. The final guidelines recommend that every area has a multi-agency psychosocial care planning group, that responses provide general support, access to social, physical and psychological support and that specific mental health interventions are only provided if indicated by a comprehensive assessment. Trauma-focused cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) is recommended for acute stress disorder or acute post-traumatic stress disorder, with other treatments with an evidence base for chronic post-traumatic stress disorder being made available if trauma-focused CBT is not tolerated.
The Delphi process allowed a consensus to be achieved in an area where there are limitations to the current evidence.
如何最好地规划和提供灾难后的心理社会关怀仍然存在激烈的争论。
制定基于证据的灾后心理社会管理指南。
进行了三轮基于网络的德尔菲流程。106 名专家使用 1 到 9 的等级对从现有证据中生成的陈述的重要性进行了评分。参与者根据后续轮次中其他人的回应重新评估了他们的原始分数。
共有 111 项声明中的 80 项(72%)达成了纳入共识。“所有应对措施都应提供药物评估和管理的途径”这一说法未达成共识。最终的指南建议每个地区都有一个多机构心理社会关怀规划小组,应对措施提供一般支持、获得社会、身体和心理支持,如果全面评估表明需要,才提供特定的心理健康干预措施。建议对急性应激障碍或急性创伤后应激障碍采用以创伤为中心的认知行为疗法(CBT),如果不能耐受以创伤为中心的 CBT,则提供有慢性创伤后应激障碍证据基础的其他治疗方法。
德尔菲流程使在当前证据存在局限性的领域达成了共识。