van As J, Hummelen J W, Buitelaar J K
Tijdschr Psychiatr. 2010;52(1):41-50.
BACKGROUND Neurofeedback (nf) is a method of treatment that is being used increasingly in the Netherlands, particularly in psychological practices. Many psychiatric and somatic symptoms are currently being treated with the help of nf. In particular, nf is being used more and more to treat attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (adhd). Despite its growing popularity, nf is still a relatively unknown treatment method in psychiatric practices.
To investigate the scientific evidence for treating adhd with nf.
We searched the literature for reports on controlled trials that investigated the effectiveness of nf on adhd. results Six controlled trials were located. The studies reported that nf had a positive effect on adhd, but all the studies were marred by methodological shortcomings.
On the basis of currently available research results, no firm conclusion can be drawn about the effectiveness of treating adhd by means of nf. In view of the fact that nf is being used more and more as a method of treatment, there is an urgent need for scientific research in this field to be well planned and carefully executed.
背景 神经反馈(nf)是一种治疗方法,在荷兰正越来越多地被使用,尤其是在心理治疗实践中。目前许多精神和躯体症状都借助神经反馈进行治疗。特别是,神经反馈越来越多地用于治疗注意力缺陷多动障碍(adhd)。尽管其越来越受欢迎,但在精神科实践中,神经反馈仍然是一种相对不为人知的治疗方法。
调查用神经反馈治疗注意力缺陷多动障碍的科学证据。
我们在文献中搜索关于研究神经反馈对注意力缺陷多动障碍有效性的对照试验报告。结果 找到了六项对照试验。这些研究报告称神经反馈对注意力缺陷多动障碍有积极作用,但所有研究都存在方法学缺陷。
根据目前可得的研究结果,无法就通过神经反馈治疗注意力缺陷多动障碍的有效性得出确凿结论。鉴于神经反馈作为一种治疗方法越来越多地被使用,迫切需要对该领域的科学研究进行精心规划和认真实施。