Engdahl B E, Speed N, Eberly R E, Schwartz J
Psychology Service, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55417.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1991 Apr;179(4):181-7. doi: 10.1097/00005053-199104000-00001.
To characterize the effects of trauma sustained more than 40 years ago, prevalence of psychiatric disorders and personality dimensions were examined in a sample of 62 former World War II POWs. The negative effects of their experiences are reflected in their multiple lifetime diagnoses and in their current personality profiles. Fifty percent met DSM-III posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) criteria within 1 year of release; 18 (29%) continued to meet the criteria 40 years later at examination (chronic PTSD). A lifetime diagnosis of generalized anxiety disorder was found for over half the entire sample; in 42% of those who never had PTSD, 38% of those with recovery from PTSD, and 94% of those with chronic PTSD. Ten percent of those without a PTSD diagnosis had experienced a depressive disorder, as had 23% of those with recovery from PTSD and 61% of the POWs with chronic PTSD. The combination of depressive and anxiety disorders also was frequent in the total sample (61%). Current MMPIs of three groups with psychiatric diagnosis were compared with those of POWs who had no diagnoses and with a group of Minnesota normal men. Profile elevations for the groups, from highest to lowest, were: POWs with chronic PTSD, POWs with recovery from PTSD, POWs with other psychiatric diagnoses, POWs with no disorders, and Minnesota normal men. Symptoms of anxiety, depression, and somatic concerns combined with the personality styles of suppression and denial characterize the current adjustment of negatively affected POWs.
为了描述40多年前遭受的创伤所产生的影响,我们对62名二战时期的前战俘进行了抽样调查,以研究精神疾病的患病率和人格维度。他们经历的负面影响体现在他们多次的终生诊断和当前的人格特征中。50%的人在获释后1年内符合《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版(DSM-III)创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的标准;40年后接受检查时,有18人(29%)仍符合该标准(慢性PTSD)。超过一半的样本终生被诊断为广泛性焦虑症;在从未患过PTSD的人中,这一比例为42%,从PTSD中康复的人中有38%,患有慢性PTSD的人中有94%。没有PTSD诊断的人中有10%经历过抑郁症,从PTSD中康复的人中有23%,患有慢性PTSD的战俘中有61%经历过抑郁症。抑郁和焦虑症的合并在总样本中也很常见(61%)。将三组有精神疾病诊断的战俘的当前明尼苏达多相个性调查表(MMPI)结果与没有诊断的战俘以及一组明尼苏达正常男性的结果进行了比较。各组的剖面图升高程度从高到低依次为:患有慢性PTSD的战俘、从PTSD中康复的战俘、有其他精神疾病诊断的战俘、没有疾病的战俘和明尼苏达正常男性。焦虑、抑郁和躯体问题的症状,再加上压抑和否认的人格风格,构成了受负面影响的战俘当前的适应状况。