Engdahl B, Dikel T N, Eberly R, Blank A
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Minneapolis, USA.
Am J Psychiatry. 1997 Nov;154(11):1576-81. doi: 10.1176/ajp.154.11.1576.
The goal of this study was to assess and describe the long-term impact of traumatic prisoner of war (POW) experiences within the context of posttraumatic psychopathology. Specifically, the authors attempted to investigate the relative degree of normative response represented by posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in comparison to other DSM axis I disorders often found to be present, either alone or concomitant with other disorders, in survivors of trauma.
A community group of 262 U.S. World War II and Korean War former POWs was recruited. These men had been exposed to the multiple traumas of combat, capture, and imprisonment, yet few had ever sought mental health treatment. They were assessed for psychopathology with diagnostic interviews and psychodiagnostic testing. Regression analyses were used to assess the contributions of age at capture, war trauma, and postwar social support to PTSD and the other diagnosed disorders.
More than half of the men (53%) met criteria for lifetime PTSD, and 29% met criteria for current PTSD. The most severely traumatized group (POWs held by the Japanese) had PTSD lifetime rates of 84% and current rates of 59%. Fifty-five percent of those with current PTSD were free from the other current axis I disorders (uncomplicated PTSD). In addition, 34% of those with lifetime PTSD had PTSD as their only lifetime axis I diagnosis. Regression analyses indicated that age at capture, severity of exposure to trauma, and postmilitary social support were moderately predictive of PTSD and only weakly predictive of other disorders.
These findings indicate that PTSD is a persistent, normative, and primary consequence of exposure to severe trauma.
本研究的目的是在创伤后精神病理学的背景下评估和描述创伤性战俘经历的长期影响。具体而言,作者试图调查创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)相对于其他通常在创伤幸存者中单独出现或与其他疾病并发的DSM轴I障碍所代表的正常反应的相对程度。
招募了一个由262名美国二战和朝鲜战争退伍战俘组成的社区群体。这些人曾遭受战斗、被俘和监禁的多重创伤,但很少有人寻求过心理健康治疗。通过诊断访谈和心理诊断测试对他们进行精神病理学评估。回归分析用于评估被俘时年龄、战争创伤和战后社会支持对PTSD及其他已诊断疾病的影响。
超过一半的男性(53%)符合终生PTSD标准,29%符合当前PTSD标准。受创伤最严重的群体(被日本人关押的战俘)终生PTSD发生率为84%,当前发生率为59%。当前患有PTSD的人中有55%没有其他当前的轴I障碍(单纯PTSD)。此外,终生患有PTSD的人中有34%将PTSD作为其唯一的终生轴I诊断。回归分析表明,被俘时年龄、创伤暴露的严重程度和退伍后的社会支持对PTSD有中度预测作用,对其他疾病只有微弱的预测作用。
这些发现表明,PTSD是暴露于严重创伤后的一种持续、正常且主要的后果。