Department of Cardiology, Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Neth Heart J. 2009 Dec;17(12):464-9. doi: 10.1007/BF03086305.
Background. Patients with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) and HCM mutation carriers are at risk of sudden cardiac death (SCD). Both groups should therefore be subject to regular cardiological testing - including risk stratification for SCD - according to international guidelines. We evaluated Dutch cardiologists' knowledge of and adherence to international guidelines on risk stratification and prevention of SCD in mutation carriers with and without manifest HCM.Methods. A questionnaire was sent to 1109 Dutch cardiologists (in training) containing case-based questions.Results. The response rate was 21%. Own general knowledge on HCM care was rated as insufficient by 63% of cardiologists. The percentage of correct answers (i.e. in agreement with international guidelines), on the case-based questions ranged from 37 to 96%, being lowest in cases with an unknown number of risk factors for SCD. A substantial portion of correct answers was based on the correct answer 'ask an expert opinion'. Significantly more correct answers were provided in cases with manifest HCM. There was little difference between the answers of cardiologists with different self-reported levels of knowledge, with different numbers of HCM patients in their practice or with different numbers of carriers without manifest HCM.Conclusion. Knowledge on risk stratification and preventive therapy was mediocre, and knowledge gaps exist, especially on HCM mutation carriers without manifest disease. Fortunately, experts are frequently asked for their opinion which might bring patient care to an adequate level. Hopefully, our results will stimulate cardiologists to follow developments in this field, thereby increasing quality of care for HCM patients and mutation carriers. (Neth Heart J 2009;17:464-9.).
肥厚型心肌病(HCM)患者和 HCM 突变携带者有发生心源性猝死(SCD)的风险。因此,这两组人群都应根据国际指南,定期进行心脏检查——包括 SCD 风险分层。我们评估了荷兰心脏病学家在 HCM 突变携带者(有或无症状)中,对风险分层和 SCD 预防的国际指南的了解和遵循情况。
我们向 1109 名(受训中)荷兰心脏病学家发送了一份包含基于病例的问题的问卷。
回复率为 21%。63%的心脏病学家认为自己对 HCM 护理的一般知识不足。基于病例的问题的正确答案(即与国际指南一致)的百分比范围为 37%至 96%,在未知 SCD 危险因素数量的情况下最低。相当一部分正确答案基于正确答案“咨询专家意见”。在有明显 HCM 的病例中,提供了更多的正确答案。自我报告的知识水平不同、实践中 HCM 患者数量不同或无症状 HCM 携带者数量不同的心脏病学家之间的答案差异不大。
风险分层和预防性治疗的知识水平一般,存在知识差距,特别是在无症状疾病的 HCM 突变携带者中。幸运的是,专家经常被要求提供意见,这可能会使患者的护理达到适当的水平。希望我们的结果将鼓励心脏病学家关注这一领域的发展,从而提高 HCM 患者和突变携带者的护理质量。(荷兰心脏杂志 2009;17:464-9)。