Chmarra Magdalena K, Grimbergen Cornelis A, Jansen Frank-Willem, Dankelman Jenny
Department of BioMechanical Engineering, Delft University of Technology, Delft, the Netherlands.
Minim Invasive Ther Allied Technol. 2010;19(1):2-11. doi: 10.3109/13645700903492977.
In minimally invasive surgery (MIS), a surgeon needs to acquire a certain level of basic psychomotor MIS skills to perform surgery safely. Evaluation of those skills is a major impediment. Although various assessment methods have been introduced, none of them came as a superior. Three aspects of assessing psychomotor MIS skills are discussed here: (i) advantages and disadvantages of currently available assessment methods, (ii) methods to objectively classify residents according to their level of psychomotor skills, and (iii) factors that influence psychomotor MIS skills. Motion analysis has a potential to be the means to deal with assessment of psychomotor skills. Together with classification methods (e.g. linear discriminant analysis), motion analysis provides an aid in deciding whether a resident is ready to move to the next level of training. Presence of factors that influence psychomotor MIS skills results in a high need for standardisation of valid tasks and setups used for the assessment of MIS skills.
在微创手术(MIS)中,外科医生需要掌握一定水平的基本运动技能才能安全地进行手术。对这些技能的评估是一个主要障碍。尽管已经引入了各种评估方法,但没有一种方法堪称卓越。本文讨论了评估运动性MIS技能的三个方面:(i)当前可用评估方法的优缺点,(ii)根据住院医师的运动技能水平进行客观分类的方法,以及(iii)影响运动性MIS技能的因素。运动分析有可能成为处理运动技能评估的手段。与分类方法(例如线性判别分析)一起,运动分析有助于确定住院医师是否准备好进入下一级别的培训。影响运动性MIS技能的因素的存在导致对用于评估MIS技能的有效任务和设置进行标准化的高度需求。