Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry and Health Sciences, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
BMC Med Educ. 2010 Jan 26;10:6. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-10-6.
There are growing reasons to use both information and communication functions of learning technologies as part of clinical education, but the literature offers few accounts of such implementations or evaluations of their impact. This paper details the process of implementing a blend of online and face-to-face learning and teaching in a clinical education setting and it reports on the educational impact of this innovation.
This study designed an online community to complement a series of on-site workshops and monitored its use over a semester. Quantitative and qualitative data recording 43 final-year medical students' and 13 clinical educators' experiences with this blended approach to learning and teaching were analysed using access, adoption and quality criteria as measures of impact.
The introduction of the online community produced high student ratings of the quality of learning and teaching and it produced student academic results that were equivalent to those from face-to-face-only learning and teaching. Staff had mixed views about using blended learning.
Projects such as this take skilled effort and time. Strong incentives are required to encourage clinical staff and students to use a new mode of communication. A more synchronous or multi-channel communication feedback system might stimulate increased adoption. Cultural change in clinical teaching is also required before clinical education can benefit more widely from initiatives such as this.
越来越有理由将学习技术的信息和通信功能用作临床教育的一部分,但文献中几乎没有关于此类实施情况或对其影响的评估的报道。本文详细介绍了在临床教育环境中混合使用在线和面对面学习和教学的过程,并报告了这一创新的教育影响。
本研究设计了一个在线社区来补充一系列现场研讨会,并在一个学期内监测其使用情况。使用访问、采用和质量标准来分析记录 43 名医学专业最后一年的学生和 13 名临床教育者在这种混合学习和教学方法中的经验的定量和定性数据,以衡量其影响。
在线社区的引入使学生对学习和教学质量的评价很高,并且产生了与面对面学习和教学相当的学生学业成绩。工作人员对使用混合学习的看法不一。
此类项目需要熟练的努力和时间。需要强有力的激励措施来鼓励临床工作人员和学生使用新的沟通模式。更同步或多渠道的沟通反馈系统可能会刺激更多的采用。在临床教育能够更广泛地受益于此类举措之前,还需要进行临床教学方面的文化变革。