University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, USA.
Neurology. 2010 Jan 26;74(4):336-43. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0b013e3181cbcd2f.
To evaluate published evidence of efficacy and safety of pharmacologic treatments for childhood spasticity due to cerebral palsy.
A multidisciplinary panel systematically reviewed relevant literature from 1966 to July 2008.
For localized/segmental spasticity, botulinum toxin type A is established as an effective treatment to reduce spasticity in the upper and lower extremities. There is conflicting evidence regarding functional improvement. Botulinum toxin type A was found to be generally safe in children with cerebral palsy; however, the Food and Drug Administration is presently investigating isolated cases of generalized weakness resulting in poor outcomes. No studies that met criteria are available on the use of phenol, alcohol, or botulinum toxin type B injections. For generalized spasticity, diazepam is probably effective in reducing spasticity, but there are insufficient data on its effect on motor function and its side-effect profile. Tizanidine is possibly effective, but there are insufficient data on its effect on function and its side-effect profile. There were insufficient data on the use of dantrolene, oral baclofen, and intrathecal baclofen, and toxicity was frequently reported.
For localized/segmental spasticity that warrants treatment, botulinum toxin type A should be offered as an effective and generally safe treatment (Level A). There are insufficient data to support or refute the use of phenol, alcohol, or botulinum toxin type B (Level U). For generalized spasticity that warrants treatment, diazepam should be considered for short-term treatment, with caution regarding toxicity (Level B), and tizanidine may be considered (Level C). There are insufficient data to support or refute use of dantrolene, oral baclofen, or continuous intrathecal baclofen (Level U).
评价已发表的用于治疗脑瘫儿童痉挛的药物治疗的疗效和安全性证据。
一个多学科专家组对 1966 年至 2008 年 7 月的相关文献进行了系统回顾。
对于局部/节段性痉挛,A型肉毒毒素已被证实是一种有效的治疗方法,可降低上下肢的痉挛程度。关于功能改善,存在相互矛盾的证据。A型肉毒毒素在脑瘫儿童中通常是安全的;然而,食品和药物管理局目前正在调查导致不良后果的孤立的全身无力病例。目前尚无关于酚、酒精或 B 型肉毒毒素注射使用的符合标准的研究。对于全身性痉挛,地西泮可能有效降低痉挛程度,但关于其对运动功能的影响及其副作用特征的数据不足。替扎尼定可能有效,但关于其对功能的影响及其副作用特征的数据不足。关于丹曲林钠、口服巴氯芬和鞘内巴氯芬的使用数据不足,且经常报道毒性。
对于需要治疗的局部/节段性痉挛,如果需要治疗,应提供 A 型肉毒毒素,因为它是一种有效且通常安全的治疗方法(A级)。没有足够的数据支持或反驳使用酚、酒精或 B 型肉毒毒素(U 级)。对于需要治疗的全身性痉挛,应考虑短期使用地西泮,注意毒性(B 级),并可考虑使用替扎尼定(C 级)。没有足够的数据支持或反驳使用丹曲林钠、口服巴氯芬或连续鞘内巴氯芬(U 级)。