Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Boston University School of Medicine, Massachusetts, USA.
Clin Anat. 2010 Apr;23(3):270-6. doi: 10.1002/ca.20920.
This study tested three techniques and two approaches to access the vocal fold (VF) by transcutaneous injection using a cadaver model. The three techniques include an anatomically informed geometric technique, flexible laryngoscope (FL) guidance, and planned injection with use of computed tomography (CT). The two approaches for injection include the thyrohyoid membrane (THM) and the cricothyroid membrane (CTM). The hypothesis was that the VF is more reliably reached with techniques using technological visualization and the THM and CTM provides equal access to the VF. A geometric approach to the VF was developed and tested on seven formalin-fixed human cadavers with three injections of 0.5 ml pigmented acrylic polymer through the CTM and one through the THM. The FL-guided technique through the THM and the CTM was tested on eight formalin-fixed human cadavers and the CT informed technique on two subjects. All tests were inspected by dissection and results recorded. Pertinent measurements and characteristics of each technique were recorded. Data were analyzed for statistical significance for each approach and technique. A chi-square analysis revealed that a technology guided technique was more successful than anatomical knowledge alone (X(2) = 6.55, P = 0.01). The null hypothesis that the VF was equally accessed through the THM and the CTM was rejected (X(2) = 5.33, P = 0.02). We found that technology guided visualization is better than anatomical knowledge alone in accessing the VF. We also found that the CTM approach provides more reliable access to the entire length of the VF.
本研究通过尸体模型测试了三种经皮注射进入声带(VF)的技术和两种方法。这三种技术包括解剖学指导的几何技术、软喉镜(FL)引导和使用计算机断层扫描(CT)进行计划注射。两种注射方法包括甲状舌骨膜(THM)和环甲膜(CTM)。假设是使用技术可视化和 THM 和 CTM 的技术更可靠地到达 VF,并且 THM 和 CTM 提供了到达 VF 的相等途径。开发了一种针对 VF 的几何方法,并在七个福尔马林固定的人体尸体上进行了测试,通过 CTM 进行了三次 0.5 毫升色素丙烯聚合物注射,一次通过 THM 进行。通过 THM 和 CTM 进行了 FL 引导技术测试,对两名受试者进行了 CT 引导技术测试。所有测试均通过解剖检查,并记录结果。记录了每种技术的相关测量和特征。对每种方法和技术的数据进行了统计意义分析。卡方分析显示,技术引导技术比单独的解剖知识更成功(X(2) = 6.55,P = 0.01)。THM 和 CTM 同样进入 VF 的无效假设被拒绝(X(2) = 5.33,P = 0.02)。我们发现,技术引导可视化在进入 VF 方面优于单独的解剖知识。我们还发现 CTM 方法更可靠地进入整个 VF 长度。