Division of Vascular Surgery, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California 94305, USA.
J Surg Educ. 2009 Nov-Dec;66(6):367-73. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2009.06.002.
OBJECTIVE: New training paradigms in vascular surgery allow for early specialization out of medical school. Surgical simulation has emerged as an educational tool for trainees to practice procedures in a controlled environment allowing interested medical students to perform procedures without compromising patient safety. The purpose of this study is to assess the ability of a simulation-based curriculum to improve the technical performance and interest level of medical students in vascular surgery. DESIGN: Prospective observational cohort study of medical student performance. SETTING: Academic medical center. PARTICIPANTS: Forty-one medical students (23 first year, 15 second year, 3 other) enrolled in a vascular surgery elective course. Students completed a survey of their interests and performed a renal stent procedure on an endovascular simulator (pretest). The curriculum consisted of didactic teaching and weekly mentored simulator sessions and concluded with a final renal stent procedure on the simulator (posttest). Objective procedural measures were determined during the pre- and posttest by the simulator, and subjective performance was graded by expert observers utilizing a structured global assessment scale. After the course, the students were surveyed as to their opinions about vascular surgery as a career option. Finally, 1 year after the course, all students were again surveyed to determine continued interest in vascular surgery. RESULTS: The objective and subjective criteria measured on the simulator and structured global assessment scale significantly improved from pre- to posttest in terms of performer technical skill, patient safety measures, and structured global assessments. Before beginning the course, 8.5% of the students expressed high interest in vascular surgery, and after completing the course 70% were seriously considering vascular surgery as a career option (p = 0.0001). More than 95% of the students responded that endovascular simulation increased their knowledge and interest in vascular surgery. In the 1-year follow-up survey (n = 23 medical students), 35% had already entered their clinical years. Seventy percent of the students were still considering vascular surgery, while several other career options were still popular including the surgical subspecialties (70%), interventional cardiology (57%), and interventional radiology (48%). Most respondents indicated the major reasons for continued interest in vascular surgery were the ability to practice endovascular procedures on the simulator (100%) and mentorship from vascular surgery faculty (78%). CONCLUSIONS: The use of high fidelity endovascular simulation within an introductory vascular surgery course improves medical student performance with respect to technical skill, patient safety parameters, and global performance assessment. Mentored exposure to endovascular procedures on the simulator positively impacts long term medical student attitudes towards vascular surgery. Simulator-based courses may have the potential to be an important component in the assessment and recruitment of medical students for future surgical training programs.
目的:血管外科学中的新培训模式允许医学生在医学院早期专业化。手术模拟已成为一种教育工具,可让学员在受控环境中练习手术,使感兴趣的医学生能够进行手术而又不影响患者安全。本研究的目的是评估基于模拟的课程是否能够提高医学生在血管外科学方面的技术表现和兴趣水平。
设计:医学生表现的前瞻性观察队列研究。
地点:学术医疗中心。
参与者:41 名医学生(23 名一年级,15 名二年级,3 名其他年级)参加了血管外科学选修课程。学生完成了对他们兴趣的调查,并在血管内模拟器上进行了肾支架手术(预测试)。课程包括教学和每周的导师模拟课程,并以在模拟器上进行最终的肾支架手术(后测)结束。在预测试和后测试期间,通过模拟器确定了客观的手术措施,并且专家观察者利用结构化的总体评估量表对主观表现进行了分级。课程结束后,学生们就他们对血管外科学作为职业选择的看法进行了调查。最后,在课程结束一年后,再次对所有学生进行调查,以确定他们对血管外科学的持续兴趣。
结果:在模拟器和结构化总体评估量表上测量的客观和主观标准在表演者技术技能、患者安全措施和结构化总体评估方面从预测试到后测试都有显著提高。在开始课程之前,8.5%的学生对血管外科学表示出浓厚的兴趣,而在完成课程后,70%的学生认真考虑将血管外科学作为职业选择(p=0.0001)。超过 95%的学生表示,血管内模拟增加了他们对血管外科学的知识和兴趣。在 1 年的随访调查(n=23 名医学生)中,35%的学生已经进入临床学年。70%的学生仍在考虑血管外科学,而其他一些职业选择仍然很受欢迎,包括外科专业(70%)、介入心脏病学(57%)和介入放射学(48%)。大多数受访者表示,对血管外科学持续感兴趣的主要原因是能够在模拟器上进行血管内手术(100%)和血管外科教员的指导(78%)。
结论:在血管外科学入门课程中使用高保真血管内模拟可以提高医学生在技术技能、患者安全参数和总体绩效评估方面的表现。在模拟器上进行血管内手术的导师指导对医学生对血管外科学的长期态度产生积极影响。基于模拟器的课程可能有潜力成为评估和招募医学生未来外科培训计划的重要组成部分。
J Acad Ophthalmol (2017). 2021-12-11
J Surg Res. 2022-11
EJVES Vasc Forum. 2022-1-23
Adv Simul (Lond). 2020-6-12
J Taibah Univ Med Sci. 2019-11-22