Amlani Amyn M, Schafer Erin C
Department of Speech and Hearing Sciences, University of North Texas, PO Box 305010, Denton, TX 76203, USA.
Trends Amplif. 2009 Dec;13(4):241-59. doi: 10.1177/1084713809352908.
The method of paired comparisons was introduced into the hearing aid literature nearly 50 years ago. Over time, studies have found paired comparisons to be sensitive, valid, and reliable in determining either the perceptual difference or relative ranking among hearing aids and electroacoustic characteristics. With the increasing number of adjustable electroacoustic parameters in today's digital hearing aids-and the lack of procedural guidelines necessary to fit many of them-the method of paired comparisons provides the clinician with the ability to compare different devices, electroacoustic characteristics, memory settings, or combinations of these variables under the listener's everyday listening conditions. Furthermore, this procedure provides the clinician with the ability to individualize the prescriptive approach-which is predicated mainly on hearing threshold data and listening in quiet-so that a combination of parameters can be set to optimize the user's listening needs in a given environment. In this article, the authors present an overview of the theoretical principle supporting this procedure, the various paired-comparison strategies and associated approaches, the advantages of this method, and recommended procedures for implementing the method of paired comparisons in the fitting of today's sophisticated hearing aids.
配对比较法近50年前就被引入助听器文献中。随着时间的推移,研究发现配对比较法在确定助听器和电声特性之间的感知差异或相对排名方面是敏感、有效且可靠的。随着当今数字助听器中可调节电声参数数量的增加,以及缺乏适配其中许多参数所需的程序指南,配对比较法使临床医生能够在听众的日常聆听条件下比较不同的设备、电声特性、记忆设置或这些变量的组合。此外,该程序使临床医生能够个性化规定性方法(该方法主要基于听力阈值数据并在安静环境中聆听),以便可以设置参数组合以在给定环境中优化用户的聆听需求。在本文中,作者概述了支持该程序的理论原理、各种配对比较策略及相关方法、该方法的优点,以及在适配当今复杂助听器时实施配对比较法的推荐程序。