Hsieh Sophie Y
Department of Healthcare Information and Management, Ming-Chuan University, 5 De-Ming Road, Gui-Shan, Taoyuan, Taiwan, ROC.
Health Serv Manage Res. 2010 Feb;23(1):5-11. doi: 10.1258/hsmr.2009.009011.
This study aims to investigate the nature and resolutions of patient complaints and further to explore the use of complaints to drive quality improvement in a selected hospital in Taiwan. A teaching hospital (i.e. the Case Hospital) in Taiwan was purposefully chosen for a case study. The author conducted the critical incident technique (CIT) using questionnaires to obtain information about the complaints and the process of their resolutions. To enhance the reliability of the study, the author also conducted non-participant observations as an outsider at the Case Hospital. In this study, 59 complainants registered 87 complaints. The CIT found that care/treatment, humaneness and communication were the most common causes of complaints. The response time of patient complaints averaged 1.76 days, except for five cases in which response time was not reported. The majority of complaints were resolved within three days. Moreover, this study found that of 149 resolutions, 105 taken by the hospital involved an explanation of the facts to complainants (n = 41), investigation of events (n = 33) and empathy with complainants (n = 31). The lack of any systematic use of complaints data was one of the most crucial failures of the Case Hospital. Instead of attempting to use such data as the basis for initiating quality improvement measures, complaints were consigned to a 'black hole' where their existence was conveniently forgotten. Based on this study, the author suggests ways to strengthen the capacity of the hospital in terms of using patient feedback and complaints to improve the quality.
本研究旨在调查患者投诉的性质及解决方式,并进一步探索如何利用投诉推动台湾某家选定医院的质量改进。台湾的一家教学医院(即案例医院)被特意选作案例研究对象。作者运用问卷调查的关键事件技术(CIT)来获取有关投诉及其解决过程的信息。为提高研究的可靠性,作者还以局外人的身份在案例医院进行了非参与式观察。在本研究中,59名投诉者提出了87起投诉。关键事件技术发现,护理/治疗、人文关怀和沟通是最常见的投诉原因。患者投诉的平均响应时间为1.76天,不过有5起案例未报告响应时间。大多数投诉在三天内得到解决。此外,本研究发现,在149项解决措施中,医院采取的105项措施包括向投诉者解释事实(n = 41)、调查事件(n = 33)以及对投诉者表示同情(n = 31)。案例医院最关键的失误之一是缺乏对投诉数据的系统运用。投诉没有被用作启动质量改进措施的依据,而是被扔进了一个“黑洞”,其存在被轻易遗忘。基于本研究,作者提出了增强医院利用患者反馈和投诉来提高质量能力的方法。