Askenazy F, Dor E, Benoit M, Dupuis G, Serret S, Myquel M, Seddiki Y
Service universitaire de psychiatrie de l'enfant et de l'adolescent, fondation Lenval, 57, avenue de la Californie, 06200 Nice, France.
Encephale. 2010 Feb;36(1):46-53. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2009.01.006. Epub 2009 May 12.
Child and adolescent catatonia has been poorly investigated. Moreover, diagnosis criteria only exist for adult psychiatry, and there are no therapeutic guidelines. The aim of this paper is to describe the case of a 14-year-old girl presenting an overlap between psychogenic and neuroleptic induced catatonia, acute treatment and ten year's follow-up.
A 14-year-old Caucasian French girl, Elsa, was admitted in February 1998 to a University adolescent mental health center with an acute psychotic disorder. She showed agitation, impulsivity (sudden engagement in inappropriate behaviour), paranoid delusions, visual and auditory hallucinations, diurnal and nocturnal urinary incontinence, lack of self-care, inadequate food intake because of fear of poisoning, and vomiting after meals leading to rapid weight loss of 5 kg. Clinical examination, laboratory tests, EEG and RMI were normal. Toxicological tests were negative. Her IQ, assessed six months before admission, was in the dull average range (70-75). Elsa was treated with loxapine 150 mg per day for one week without improvement and this was then replaced by haloperidol 30 mg per day. One week after the start of haloperidol her agitation, impulsivity, and hallucinatory symptoms decreased. Twenty four days after loxapine introduction and 17 days after the haloperidol, her condition deteriorated rapidly over less than 48 hours. She exhibited immobility, minimal response to stimuli, staring and catalepsy with waxy flexibility. The diagnosis of catatonia was established. Examination revealed tremulous extremities, tachychardia (110 pm) and apyrexia. Creatine phosphokinase levels were 106 UI/l (normal range 0-250). Human immunodeficiency virus, hepatitis, listeria and Lyme serology were negative. Cerebrospinal fluid analysis was normal. Haloperidol was stopped and intravenous clonazepam 5mg/kg was begun. It was not possible to obtain signed consent from the two parents for Electroconvulsive therapy. The patient was transferred to a pediatric intensive care unit. The treatment was standard parenteral nutrition, nursing, intravenous clonazepam 0.05 mg/kg, with regular attendance by a child psychiatrist. Elsa stayed three weeks in this condition. She then began to notice the child psychiatrist, and a few days later she was able to carry out simple requests. Elsa was transferred to an adolescent psychiatric unit. As soon as she could eat by herself again, carbamazepine 400mg per day was begun. Her agitation reduced at a carbamazepine level of 7 mg/l. One month later her condition was stable. However, language difficulties persisted for a further six months. One year after the episode she scored 66 on a repeat IQ test and her RMI was normal. She exhibited no significant residual symptoms except some cognitive impairment. She integrated into a special education facility. These attempts to stop the carbamazepine were followed by depressed mood, aggressiveness and impulsivity; carbamazepine was finally stopped successfully after seven years. Ten years later, Elsa is the mother of two young children and is able to take care of them. She has never had a relapse of her psychotic disorder or catatonic state.
The etiopathogenic diagnosis is problematic. Some indices in the familial history may suggest a traumatic event. But one to the total residual amnesia it was never confirmed, and traumatic catatonia are extremely rare. Normal CPK levels, with autonomic disturbance limited to tachycardia and the lack of resolution after discontinuance of medication, argues against a diagnosis of neuroleptic malignant syndrome (NMS). But CPK levels are non specific, and NMS without pyrexia has been described. The occurrence of the catatonic syndrome 21 days after the first dose of a neuroleptic could be diagnostic. This case involved a non organic catatonic psychosis followed by neuroleptic induced catatonia. Catatonia is described as a risk factor for the development of NMS and some consider NMS to be a variant of malignant catatonia. The interest of this report is (1) it reinforces the need to be cautious before prescribing neuroleptics in adolescents presenting with symptoms of catatonia; (2) the complete recovery from catatonia after treatment with intensive care and more than three weeks of intravenous clonazepam without the use of ECT and (3) the effectiveness of carbamazepine over a long period of follow-up. Although trials on carbamazepine in catatonia are published, there are no data available for the control of residual symptoms or the long term prognosis, especially in child and adolescent psychiatry.
儿童和青少年紧张症一直未得到充分研究。此外,诊断标准仅存在于成人精神病学领域,且尚无治疗指南。本文旨在描述一名14岁女孩的病例,该病例呈现出心因性和抗精神病药物所致紧张症的重叠情况,并介绍其急性治疗及十年随访情况。
1998年2月,一名14岁的法国白人女孩埃尔莎因急性精神障碍入住一所大学的青少年心理健康中心。她表现出躁动、冲动(突然出现不当行为)、偏执妄想、视幻觉和听幻觉、昼夜尿失禁、缺乏自理能力、因害怕中毒而饮食摄入不足以及餐后呕吐,导致体重迅速减轻5千克。临床检查、实验室检查、脑电图和核磁共振成像均正常。毒理学检查呈阴性。入院前六个月评估的智商处于平均偏低水平(70 - 75)。埃尔莎每天服用150毫克洛沙平治疗一周,病情无改善,随后改为每天服用30毫克氟哌啶醇。开始使用氟哌啶醇一周后,她的躁动、冲动和幻觉症状有所减轻。在使用洛沙平24天后以及氟哌啶醇17天后,她的病情在不到48小时内迅速恶化。她表现出不动、对刺激反应极小、凝视和蜡样屈曲的僵住状态。紧张症的诊断得以确立。检查发现四肢震颤、心动过速(110次/分钟)且无发热。肌酸磷酸激酶水平为106 UI/l(正常范围0 - 250)。人类免疫缺陷病毒、肝炎、李斯特菌和莱姆病血清学检查均为阴性。脑脊液分析正常。停用氟哌啶醇,开始静脉注射氯硝西泮,剂量为5毫克/千克。无法获得患儿父母双方对电休克治疗的签署同意书。患者被转至儿科重症监护病房。治疗措施包括标准的肠外营养、护理、静脉注射氯硝西泮0.05毫克/千克,并有儿童精神科医生定期查房。埃尔莎在此状态下持续了三周。之后她开始注意到儿童精神科医生,几天后能够执行简单指令。埃尔莎被转至青少年精神科病房。她一旦能够再次自行进食,就开始每天服用400毫克卡马西平。当卡马西平血药浓度达到7毫克/升时,她的躁动有所减轻。一个月后她的病情稳定。然而,语言困难又持续了六个月。发病一年后,她再次进行智商测试得分为66,核磁共振成像正常。除了一些认知障碍外,她没有明显的残留症状。她融入了一所特殊教育机构。停用卡马西平的尝试引发了情绪低落、攻击性和冲动行为;七年后最终成功停用卡马西平。十年后,埃尔莎是两个幼儿的母亲,能够照顾他们。她的精神障碍或紧张症状态从未复发。
病因诊断存在问题。家族史中的一些指标可能提示有创伤性事件。但由于完全遗忘残留,从未得到证实,且创伤性紧张症极为罕见。肌酸磷酸激酶水平正常,自主神经紊乱仅限于心动过速,且停药后无缓解,这与抗精神病药物恶性综合征(NMS)的诊断相悖。但肌酸磷酸激酶水平不具有特异性,且无发热的NMS也有过描述。在首次使用抗精神病药物21天后出现紧张症综合征可能具有诊断意义。该病例涉及非器质性紧张性精神病,随后出现抗精神病药物所致紧张症。紧张症被描述为NMS发生的一个危险因素,一些人认为NMS是恶性紧张症的一种变体。本报告的意义在于:(1)强调在为有紧张症症状的青少年开抗精神病药物之前需谨慎;(2)通过重症监护和超过三周的静脉注射氯硝西泮治疗,未使用电休克治疗,紧张症完全康复;(3)卡马西平在长期随访中有效。尽管有关于卡马西平治疗紧张症的试验发表,但尚无控制残留症状或长期预后的数据,尤其是在儿童和青少年精神病学领域。