Department of Internal Medicine/Cardiology, Krankenhaus Barmherzige Schwestern, Seilerstätte 4, 4010 Linz, Austria.
Am J Emerg Med. 2010 Feb;28(2):159-65. doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2008.10.028.
Recommendations for optimal first-shock energies with biphasic waveforms are conflicting. We evaluated prospectively the relation between type and duration of atrial tachyarrhythmias and the probability of successful cardioversion with a specific biphasic shock waveform to develop recommendations for the initial energy setting aiming at the lowest total cumulative energy with 2 or less consecutive shocks.
We analyzed 453 consecutive patients undergoing their first transthoracic electrical cardioversion, including 358 attempts for atrial fibrillation (AF) and 95 attempts for atrial flutter (AFL) or atrial tachycardia (AT). A step-up protocol with a truncated exponential biphasic waveform starting at 50 J was used. Total cumulative energies were estimated under the assumption of a 2-tiered escalating shock protocol with different initial energy settings and a "rescue shock" of 250 J for AFL/AT or 360 J for AF. The initial energy setting leading to the lowest total cumulative energy was regarded as the optimal first-shock level.
Cardioversion was successful in 448 patients (cumulative efficacy, 99 %). In patients with AFL/AT, the lowest total cumulative energy was attained with an initial energy setting of 50 J. In patients with AF, lowest values were achieved with an initial energy of 100 J for arrhythmia durations of 2 days or less and an initial energy of 150 J for arrhythmia durations of more than 2 days.
We recommend an initial energy setting of 50 J in patients with AFL/AT, of 100 J in patients with AF 2 days or less, and of 150 J with AF more than 2 days.
关于双相波的最佳初始电击能量的推荐意见存在冲突。我们前瞻性地评估了房性心动过速的类型和持续时间与使用特定双相波电击的转复成功率之间的关系,旨在制定初始能量设置的建议,以用 2 次或更少连续电击实现最低总累积能量。
我们分析了 453 例连续接受首次经胸电复律的患者,包括 358 次心房颤动(AF)和 95 次心房扑动(AFL)或心房颤动(AT)尝试。使用起始能量为 50 J 的截断指数双相波进行逐步递增方案。假设采用不同初始能量设置的 2 级递增电击方案和 AFL/AT 的 250 J 或 AF 的 360 J“挽救电击”,估计总累积能量。将导致最低总累积能量的初始能量设置视为最佳初始电击水平。
448 例患者(累积有效率为 99%)转复成功。在 AFL/AT 患者中,最低的总累积能量是通过初始能量设置为 50 J 实现的。在 AF 患者中,对于持续时间为 2 天或更短的心律失常,初始能量为 100 J,对于持续时间超过 2 天的心律失常,初始能量为 150 J,可获得最低值。
我们建议在 AFL/AT 患者中初始能量设置为 50 J,在持续时间为 2 天或更短的 AF 患者中初始能量设置为 100 J,在持续时间超过 2 天的 AF 患者中初始能量设置为 150 J。