Ortega J A, Wharam M, Gehan E A, Ragab A H, Crist W, Webber B, Wiener E S, Haeberlen V, Maurer H M
Division of Hematology-Oncology, Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, CA 90054-0700.
J Clin Oncol. 1991 May;9(5):796-801. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1991.9.5.796.
Soft tissue sarcomas of the paraspinal region comprised 3.3% (56 of 1,688) of the patients entered and eligible on Intergroup Rhabdomyosarcoma Studies I (IRS-I) and II (IRS-II) (1972 to 1984). These lesions tended to be greater than 5 cm in diameter at diagnosis, invaded the spinal extradural space, and were of the extraosseous Ewing's sarcoma or undifferentiated sarcoma subtype in 55% (30 of 56) of the cases. Patients with tumors in clinical groups II, III, and IV were treated with radiotherapy (XRT) and vincristine-dactinomycin (VA) or VA plus cyclophosphamide (VAC) +/- doxorubicin. Clinical group I patients treated on IRS-II did not receive XRT, while those on IRS-I were randomized to receive VAC +/- XRT. Forty-four of the paraspinal patients (79%) achieved a complete response (CR) compared with 77% (1,260 of 1,632) for patients with disease in other sites. Twenty-seven patients (55%) subsequently relapsed (five local, three regional, four local and distant, and 14 distant). The proportion of patients surviving 5 years by clinical group (stage) from I to IV were 50%, 50%, 62%, and 27%, respectively. Paraspinal patients had somewhat poorer survival than patients with disease in other sites, both in IRS-I and IRS-II; the percentage of paraspinal patients surviving 5 years was 50% and 52% for IRS-I and IRS-II, respectively, whereas these percentages were 55% and 63% for patients with disease in other sites. Histology did not influence the CR rate, but unexpectedly, patients who had embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS) had the poorest overall survival rate. We concluded that patients with paraspinal lesions may require extended-field radiation therapy to reduce the high local failure rate and more intensive chemotherapy to achieve better local and systemic tumor control.
脊柱旁软组织肉瘤占参加并符合横纹肌肉瘤协作组研究I(IRS-I)和研究II(IRS-II)(1972年至1984年)标准的患者的3.3%(1688例中的56例)。这些病变在诊断时直径往往大于5厘米,侵犯脊柱硬膜外间隙,55%(56例中的30例)的病例为骨外尤文肉瘤或未分化肉瘤亚型。临床分组为II、III和IV组的肿瘤患者接受了放射治疗(XRT)以及长春新碱-放线菌素(VA)或VA加环磷酰胺(VAC)+/-阿霉素治疗。在IRS-II研究中接受治疗的临床I组患者未接受XRT,而在IRS-I研究中的患者则被随机分配接受VAC+/-XRT。44例脊柱旁患者(79%)实现了完全缓解(CR),而其他部位疾病患者的完全缓解率为77%(1632例中的1260例)。27例患者(55%)随后复发(5例局部复发、3例区域复发、4例局部和远处复发以及14例远处复发)。从I期到IV期,各临床分组(分期)的5年生存率分别为50%、50%、62%和27%。无论是在IRS-I还是IRS-II研究中,脊柱旁患者的生存率均略低于其他部位疾病的患者;在IRS-I和IRS-II研究中,脊柱旁患者的5年生存率分别为50%和52%,而其他部位疾病患者的这一比例分别为55%和63%。组织学类型不影响完全缓解率,但出乎意料的是,患有胚胎性横纹肌肉瘤(RMS)的患者总体生存率最差。我们得出结论,脊柱旁病变患者可能需要扩大野放射治疗以降低高局部失败率,并需要更强化的化疗以实现更好的局部和全身肿瘤控制。