Division of Clinical Neurosciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, Scotland.
Stroke. 2010 Apr;41(4):685-90. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.109.572495. Epub 2010 Feb 18.
It is not always clear whether, how, and when to undertake further radiological investigation of spontaneous (nontraumatic) intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH).
We systematically reviewed Ovid MEDLINE and EMBASE databases for studies of the diagnostic utility of radiological investigations of the cause(s) of ICH. We sent a structured survey to neurologists, stroke specialists, neurosurgeons, and neuroradiologists in the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, and France to assess whether, how, and when they would investigate supratentorial ICH.
This systematic review detected 20 relevant studies (including 1933 patients), which either quantified the yield of a radiological investigation/imaging strategy (n=15) or compared 2 imaging techniques (n=5). Six hundred ninety-two (49%) physicians responded to the survey. Further investigation would have been undertaken by the following: 99% of respondents, for younger (38 to 43 years), normotensive adults with lobar or deep ICH; 76%, for older (age 72 to 83 years), normotensive adults with deep ICH; and 31%, for older adults with deep ICH and prestroke hypertension. Younger patient age was the strongest influence on the decision to further investigate ICH (odds ratio=16; 95% confidence interval, 13 to 20), followed by the absence of prestroke hypertension (odds ratio=5; 95% confidence interval, 4 to 6) and lobar ICH location (odds ratio=2; 95% confidence interval, 1 to 2).
The paucity of studies on the diagnostic utility of imaging investigations of the cause(s) of ICH may contribute to the variation observed in when and how and which patients are investigated in current clinical practice. Studies comparing different types of diagnostic strategies are required.
自发性(非外伤性)脑出血(ICH)的病因学诊断,何时、如何以及是否需要进一步进行影像学检查,并不总是很明确。
我们系统地检索了 Ovid MEDLINE 和 EMBASE 数据库,以寻找关于 ICH 病因学诊断影像学检查的诊断效用的研究。我们向英国、荷兰和法国的神经科医生、卒中专家、神经外科医生和神经放射科医生发送了一份结构化调查问卷,以评估他们是否会以及如何、何时对幕上 ICH 进行检查。
本系统综述共发现 20 项相关研究(共纳入 1933 例患者),其中 15 项研究量化了影像学检查/成像策略的检出率,5 项研究比较了 2 种影像学技术。共有 692 名(49%)医生对调查问卷做出了回应。以下情况下会进一步进行检查:99%的调查对象会对年轻(38 至 43 岁)、非高血压、皮质下或深部 ICH 患者进行进一步检查;76%的调查对象会对老年(72 至 83 岁)、非高血压、深部 ICH 患者进行进一步检查;31%的调查对象会对老年、深部 ICH 且伴有卒中前高血压患者进行进一步检查。年轻的患者年龄是影响进一步检查 ICH 决定的最强因素(比值比=16;95%置信区间,13 至 20),其次是无卒中前高血压(比值比=5;95%置信区间,4 至 6)和皮质下 ICH 部位(比值比=2;95%置信区间,1 至 2)。
影像学检查对 ICH 病因学诊断的效用的研究较少,这可能导致当前临床实践中何时、如何以及对哪些患者进行检查存在差异。需要开展比较不同诊断策略类型的研究。