Public Policy Program, Simon Fraser University Vancouver - Harbour Centre Campus, 515 West Hastings Street, Vancouver, BC V6B 5K3, Canada.
Int J Equity Health. 2010 Feb 11;9:5. doi: 10.1186/1475-9276-9-5.
Women's health research strives to make change. It seeks to produce knowledge that promotes action on the variety of factors that affect women's lives and their health. As part of this general movement, important strides have been made to raise awareness of the health effects of sex and gender. The resultant base of knowledge has been used to inform health research, policy, and practice. Increasingly, however, the need to pay better attention to the inequities among women that are caused by racism, colonialism, ethnocentrism, heterosexism, and able-bodism, is confronting feminist health researchers and activists. Researchers are seeking new conceptual frameworks that can transform the design of research to produce knowledge that captures how systems of discrimination or subordination overlap and "articulate" with one another. An emerging paradigm for women's health research is intersectionality. Intersectionality places an explicit focus on differences among groups and seeks to illuminate various interacting social factors that affect human lives, including social locations, health status, and quality of life. This paper will draw on recently emerging intersectionality research in the Canadian women's health context in order to explore the promises and practical challenges of the processes involved in applying an intersectionality paradigm. We begin with a brief overview of why the need for an intersectionality approach has emerged within the context of women's health research and introduce current thinking about how intersectionality can inform and transform health research more broadly. We then highlight novel Canadian research that is grappling with the challenges in addressing issues of difference and diversity. In the analysis of these examples, we focus on a largely uninvestigated aspect of intersectionality research - the challenges involved in the process of initiating and developing such projects and, in particular, the meaning and significance of social locations for researchers and participants who utilize an intersectionality approach. The examples highlighted in the paper represent important shifts in the health field, demonstrating the potential of intersectionality for examining the social context of women's lives, as well as developing methods which elucidate power, create new knowledge, and have the potential to inform appropriate action to bring about positive social change.
女性健康研究致力于推动变革。它旨在产生知识,以促进对影响女性生活和健康的各种因素采取行动。作为这一总体运动的一部分,已经在提高对性和性别健康影响的认识方面取得了重要进展。由此产生的知识基础被用于为健康研究、政策和实践提供信息。然而,越来越需要更好地关注种族主义、殖民主义、种族中心主义、异性恋主义和健全主义等因素造成的女性不平等问题,这正在使女权主义健康研究人员和活动家面临挑战。研究人员正在寻求新的概念框架,以改变研究设计,从而产生能够捕捉到歧视或从属制度相互重叠和“相互作用”的知识。女性健康研究的一个新兴范式是交叉性。交叉性明确关注群体之间的差异,并试图阐明影响人类生活的各种相互作用的社会因素,包括社会地位、健康状况和生活质量。本文将借鉴加拿大女性健康背景下最近出现的交叉性研究,探讨在应用交叉性范式时所涉及的过程的承诺和实际挑战。我们首先简要概述了为什么在女性健康研究背景下需要采用交叉性方法,并介绍了当前关于交叉性如何更广泛地为健康研究提供信息和改变健康研究的思路。然后,我们突出了加拿大的新研究,这些研究正在应对解决差异和多样性问题所面临的挑战。在对这些例子的分析中,我们重点关注交叉性研究中一个在很大程度上未被研究的方面——即发起和开展此类项目所涉及的挑战,特别是对于利用交叉性方法的研究人员和参与者来说,社会地位的意义和重要性。本文所强调的例子代表了健康领域的重要转变,展示了交叉性在考察女性生活的社会背景、制定阐明权力、创造新知识并有可能为带来积极社会变革的适当行动提供信息的方法方面的潜力。