Singer Adam J, McClain Steve A, Taira Breena R, Rooney Jean, Steinhauff Nicole, Rosenberg Lior
Department of Emergency Medicine and the Division of Laboratory Animal Research, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York, USA.
J Burn Care Res. 2010 Mar-Apr;31(2):304-9. doi: 10.1097/BCR.0b013e3181d0f4d4.
Deep burns are associated with the formation of an eschar, which delays healing and increases the risk of infection. Surgical debridement of the eschar is, at present, the fastest means to achieve an eschar-free bed, but the process can not differentiate between the viable tissue and the eschar and follow the minute irregularities of the interface between the two. We evaluated the efficacy and selectivity of a novel enzymatic bromelain-based debriding agent, Debrase Gel Dressing (Debrase), in a porcine comb burn model. We hypothesized that Debrase would result in rapid debridement of the eschar without adverse effects on the surrounding uninjured skin. This is a prospective, controlled, animal experiment. Five domestic pigs (20-25 kg) were used in this study. Sixteen burns were created on each animal's dorsum using a brass comb with four rectangular prongs preheated in boiling water and applied for 30 seconds, resulting in four rectangular 10 x 20 mm full-thickness burns and separated by three 5 x 20 mm unburned interspaces representing the zone of stasis. The burned keratin layer (blisters) was removed, and the burns were treated with a single, topical, Debrase or control vehicle application for 4 hours. The Debrase/control was then wiped off using a metal forceps handle, and the burns were treated with a topical silver sulfadiazine (SSD). The wounds were observed, and full-thickness biopsies were obtained at 4 and 48 hours for evidence of dermal thickness, vascular thrombosis, and burn depth, both within the comb burns and the unburned interspaces in between them. Chi-square and t tests are used for data analysis. A single 4-hour topical application of Debrase resulted in rapid and complete eschar dissolution of all the burns in which the keratin layer was removed. The remaining dermis was thinner (1.1 +/- 0.7 mm) than in the control burns (2.1 +/- 0.3 mm; difference 0.9 mm [95% confidence interval: 0.3-1.4]) and was viable with no injury to the normal surrounding skin or to the unburned interspaces between the burns, which represents the zone of stasis. In control burns, the entire thickness of the dermis was necrotic. At 48 hours, Debrase-treated areas were found partially desiccated under SSD treatment. The unburned interspaces demonstrated partial-thickness necrosis in two third and full-thickness necrosis in one third of wounds. In contrast, full-thickness necrosis was noted in all control interspaces (P = .05). In a porcine comb burn model, a single, 4-hour topical application of Debrase resulted in rapid removal of the necrotic layer of the dermis with preservation of unburned tissues. At 48 hours, SSD treatment resulted in superficial tissue damage and partial preservation of the unburned interspaces.
深度烧伤与焦痂形成有关,焦痂会延迟愈合并增加感染风险。目前,手术切除焦痂是实现无焦痂创面的最快方法,但该过程无法区分存活组织和焦痂,也无法追踪两者之间界面的细微不规则之处。我们在猪梳状烧伤模型中评估了一种新型的基于菠萝蛋白酶的酶促清创剂Debrase凝胶敷料(Debrase)的疗效和选择性。我们假设Debrase能快速清除焦痂,且对周围未受伤皮肤无不良影响。这是一项前瞻性、对照动物实验。本研究使用了5头家猪(20 - 25千克)。在每只动物的背部制造16处烧伤,使用在沸水中预热的带有四个矩形齿的黄铜梳子,按压30秒,形成四个10×20毫米的矩形全层烧伤,中间由三个5×20毫米未烧伤的间隙隔开,代表淤滞区。去除烧伤部位的角质层(水泡),然后对烧伤部位单次局部应用Debrase或对照剂,持续4小时。之后用金属镊子柄擦去Debrase/对照剂,并用磺胺嘧啶银(SSD)局部治疗烧伤。观察伤口情况,并在4小时和48小时获取全层活检样本,以获取梳状烧伤部位及其之间未烧伤间隙的真皮厚度、血管血栓形成和烧伤深度的证据。数据分析采用卡方检验和t检验。单次4小时局部应用Debrase可使所有去除角质层的烧伤焦痂迅速完全溶解。剩余的真皮比对照烧伤的真皮更薄(1.1±0.7毫米)(对照烧伤为2.1±0.3毫米;差异为0.9毫米[95%置信区间:0.3 - 1.4]),且存活,周围正常皮肤和烧伤之间未烧伤的间隙(代表淤滞区)未受损伤。在对照烧伤中,真皮全层坏死。在48小时时,发现接受Debrase治疗的区域在SSD治疗下部分干燥。未烧伤的间隙在三分之二的伤口中表现为部分厚度坏死,在三分之一的伤口中表现为全层坏死。相比之下,所有对照间隙均出现全层坏死(P = 0.05)。在猪梳状烧伤模型中单次4小时局部应用Debrase可快速去除真皮坏死层,同时保留未烧伤组织。在48小时时,SSD治疗导致浅表组织损伤,并部分保留了未烧伤的间隙。