Université Paris Descartes, Service de Gynécologie Obstétrique, Centre Hospitalo-Universitaire Necker-Enfants Malades, AP-HP, 149 rue de Sèvres, Paris, France.
Prenat Diagn. 2010 Apr;30(4):361-7. doi: 10.1002/pd.2469.
The aims of this study were (1) to assess the accuracy of estimated fetal weight (EFW) in twins and (2) to assess the accuracy of sonographic examination to predict birth weight discordance (BWD).
We retrospectively analyzed collected data on twin pregnancies between 2004 and 2007. All twin pregnancies with at least one ultrasound (US) examination within 15 days of delivery were included in this study. EFW was calculated according to Hadlock1, Hadlock2, Ong, Shepard and Warsof formulas. Mean and SD of the standardized errors and percentage of newborns with birth weight (BW) within 10% of EFW were calculated.
Two hundred eighty-three twin pregnancies were included. Mean and SD (%) of the standardized errors were 1.54 +/- 12.19, 0.19 +/- 11.87, 10.93 +/- 15.55, - 1.91 +/- 14.93 and 5.37 +/- 14.91 for Hadlock1, Hadlock2, Shepard, Ong and Warsof formulas, respectively. Hadlock2's formula allowed for the highest proportion of newborns with BW within 10% of EFW and it also performed best to predict discordance of more than 25% as assessed by area under the ROC curve.
Sonographic prediction of inter-twin BWD within 15 days of delivery seems to be accurate enough for routine clinical use. Performance and predictive values depend on the threshold chosen to define EFW and BW discordance.
本研究旨在(1)评估双胎胎儿体重估计(EFW)的准确性,(2)评估超声检查预测出生体重差异(BWD)的准确性。
我们回顾性分析了 2004 年至 2007 年间收集的双胎妊娠数据。所有至少有一次超声(US)检查在分娩前 15 天内的双胎妊娠均纳入本研究。EFW 根据 Hadlock1、Hadlock2、Ong、Shepard 和 Warsof 公式计算。计算标准化误差的均值和标准差以及出生体重(BW)在 EFW 内 10%的新生儿比例。
共纳入 283 例双胎妊娠。Hadlock1、Hadlock2、Shepard、Ong 和 Warsof 公式的标准化误差均值和标准差(%)分别为 1.54+/-12.19、0.19+/-11.87、10.93+/-15.55、-1.91+/-14.93 和 5.37+/-14.91。Hadlock2 公式允许最大比例的新生儿 BW 在 EFW 的 10%内,并且它在预测超过 25%的 BWD 差异方面表现最佳,ROC 曲线下面积评估。
分娩前 15 天内超声预测双胎 BWD 似乎足够准确,可用于常规临床应用。性能和预测值取决于用于定义 EFW 和 BW 差异的阈值。