Iyer Veena R, Hahn Peter F, Blaszkowsky Lawrence S, Thayer Sarah P, Halpern Elkan F, Harisinghani Mukesh G
Department of Radiology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02114, USA.
J Am Coll Radiol. 2010 Mar;7(3):205-10. doi: 10.1016/j.jacr.2009.10.014.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the added utility of embedding images for findings described in radiology text reports to referring clinicians.
Thirty-five cases referred for abdominal CT scans in 2007 and 2008 were included. Referring physicians were asked to view text-only reports, followed by the same reports with pertinent images embedded. For each pair of reports, a questionnaire was administered. A 5-point, Likert-type scale was used to assess if the clinical query was satisfactorily answered by the text-only report. A "yes-or-no" question was used to assess whether the report with images answered the clinical query better; a positive answer to this question generated "yes-or-no" queries to examine whether the report with images helped in making a more confident decision on management, whether it reduced time spent in forming the plan, and whether it altered management. The questionnaire asked whether a radiologist would be contacted with queries on reading the text-only report and the report with images.
In 32 of 35 cases, the text-only reports satisfactorily answered the clinical queries. In these 32 cases, the reports with attached images helped in making more confident management decisions and reduced time in planning management. Attached images altered management in 2 cases. Radiologists would have been consulted for clarifications in 21 and 10 cases on reading the text-only reports and the reports with embedded images, respectively.
Providing relevant images with reports saves time, increases physicians' confidence in deciding treatment plans, and can alter management.
本研究的目的是评估在放射学文本报告中嵌入图像对转诊临床医生了解检查结果的额外作用。
纳入2007年和2008年转诊进行腹部CT扫描的35例病例。要求转诊医生先查看纯文本报告,然后再查看嵌入相关图像的相同报告。针对每对报告发放一份问卷。采用5分制李克特量表评估纯文本报告是否令人满意地回答了临床问题。使用“是或否”问题评估带图像的报告是否能更好地回答临床问题;对该问题的肯定回答会引发“是或否”的追问,以考察带图像的报告是否有助于做出更有信心的管理决策、是否减少了制定计划所花费的时间以及是否改变了管理方式。问卷还询问对于纯文本报告和带图像的报告有疑问时是否会联系放射科医生。
35例病例中有32例,纯文本报告令人满意地回答了临床问题。在这32例病例中,带附加图像的报告有助于做出更有信心的管理决策,并减少了制定管理计划的时间。附加图像在2例中改变了管理方式。分别有21例和10例在阅读纯文本报告和带嵌入图像的报告时有疑问会咨询放射科医生。
报告中提供相关图像可节省时间、增强医生制定治疗计划的信心,并可改变管理方式。