School of Clinical and Experimental Medicine, College of Medicine and Dental Sciences, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, UK.
J Neurol. 2010 Aug;257(8):1274-8. doi: 10.1007/s00415-010-5506-7. Epub 2010 Mar 3.
Guidelines recommend imaging only headache patients with sinister features in the history or on examination. We prospectively collected data on imaging newly presenting patients to a UK headache service. CT and MRI results were classified as normal or showing an insignificant or significant abnormality. Over 5 years, 3,655 new patients (69% female; mean age 42.0 years) with headache disorders were seen. Five hundred thirty (14.5%) underwent imaging with large differences in the proportion referred by each consultant. There were more insignificant abnormalities on MRI (46%) than CT (28%). There were 11 significantly abnormal results (2.1% of those imaged). Significant abnormalities were found in patients diagnosed with migraine in 1.2% and in 0.9% of those with tension-type headache. Significant abnormalities in those suspected to have an intracranial abnormality occurred in 5.5%. This supports the practice of selecting patients with suspicious findings for imaging, rather than imaging all patients.
指南建议仅对有险恶特征的头痛患者进行影像学检查。我们前瞻性地收集了英国头痛服务中心新出现的头痛患者的影像学数据。将 CT 和 MRI 的结果分为正常、无明显异常或有明显异常。在 5 年的时间里,有 3655 名新的头痛障碍患者(69%为女性;平均年龄 42.0 岁)接受了检查。其中 530 名(14.5%)接受了影像学检查,每位顾问推荐的比例差异很大。MRI 上的无明显异常结果(46%)多于 CT(28%)。有 11 个明显异常的结果(占影像学检查患者的 2.1%)。在诊断为偏头痛的患者中发现了 1.2%的明显异常,在紧张型头痛患者中发现了 0.9%的明显异常。在疑似颅内异常的患者中发现了 5.5%的明显异常。这支持了选择有可疑发现的患者进行影像学检查的做法,而不是对所有患者进行影像学检查。