Ullah S, Finch C F
School of Human Movement and Sport Sciences, University of Ballarat, Mt Helen, VIC, 3353, Australia.
Osteoporos Int. 2010 Dec;21(12):2125-34. doi: 10.1007/s00198-010-1189-2. Epub 2010 Mar 4.
Policy decisions about the allocation of current and future resources should be based on the most accurate predictions possible. A functional data analysis (FDA) approach improves the understanding of current trends and future incidence of injuries. FDA provides more valid and reliable long-term predictions than commonly used methods.
Accurate information about predicted future injury rates is needed to inform public health investment decisions. It is critical that such predictions derived from the best available statistical models to minimise possible error in future injury incidence rates.
FDA approach was developed to improve long-term predictions but is yet to be widely applied to injury epidemiology or other epidemiological research. Using the specific example of modelling age-specific annual incidence of fall-related severe head injuries of older people during 1970-2004 and predicting rates up to 2024 in Finland, this paper explains the principles behind FDA and demonstrates their superiority in terms of prediction accuracy over the more commonly reported ordinary least squares (OLS) approach.
Application of the FDA approach shows that the incidence of fall-related severe head injuries would increase by 2.3-2.6-fold by 2024 compared to 2004. The FDA predictions had 55% less prediction error than traditional OLS predictions when compared to actual data.
In summary, FDA provides more accurate predictions of long-term incidence trends than commonly used methods. The production of FDA prediction intervals for future injury incidence rates gives likely guidance as to the likely accuracy of these predictions.
关于当前和未来资源分配的政策决策应基于尽可能准确的预测。功能数据分析(FDA)方法有助于更好地理解当前趋势和未来伤害发生率。与常用方法相比,FDA能提供更有效、更可靠的长期预测。
需要准确的未来伤害率预测信息,以便为公共卫生投资决策提供依据。至关重要的是,此类预测应源自最佳可用统计模型,以尽量减少未来伤害发生率的可能误差。
FDA方法旨在改进长期预测,但尚未广泛应用于伤害流行病学或其他流行病学研究。本文以1970 - 2004年期间芬兰老年人与跌倒相关的严重头部损伤的年龄特异性年发病率建模为例,并预测到2024年的发病率,解释了FDA背后的原理,并证明了其在预测准确性方面优于更常报道的普通最小二乘法(OLS)。
FDA方法的应用表明,到2024年,与跌倒相关的严重头部损伤的发病率将比2004年增加2.3 - 2.6倍。与实际数据相比,FDA预测的误差比传统OLS预测少55%。
总之,与常用方法相比,FDA能更准确地预测长期发病率趋势。为未来伤害发生率生成FDA预测区间,可为这些预测的可能准确性提供指导。