Institute of Social Medicine, School of Medicine University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia.
Eur J Public Health. 2011 Apr;21(2):247-53. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/ckq010. Epub 2010 Mar 9.
Health workforce competencies are considered crucial for attaining high-quality health care in the current market principles approach to the provision of health services. This study explored the competencies and the perceived competence gap of management personnel in public primary healthcare.
During 2007 and 2008, 14 management teams of Belgrade primary health-care centres were questioned before and after management training in six competency categories. Competency mean differences (95% confidence interval) by gender, educational level, experience and position were analysed by Leven, Snedecor or Welch statistics, and Student's t-test for comparison of two independent samples. Mixed Model Analysis clarified possible interactions of the managers' baseline characteristics and competency task ratings. Differences between team ratings were analysed by analysis of variance (ANOVA) or the Kruskal-Wallis test. The General Linear Model Repeated Measures Analysis determined interactions and competency gap changes. Differences were statistically significant at P ≤ 0.05.
Female managers developed higher competency levels after training in communication skills and problem solving. Top managers rated assessing performance of higher importance, while chief nurses emphasized the importance of leading. Before training, the estimated competency gap was generally the highest in assessing performance (6.29), followed by team building (5.81) and planning and priority setting (5.70). Five months after training, the highest gap remained in assessing performance, although it was reduced considerably to 3.18 (P < 0.0005).
Managers rated core competencies as highly important. The reduction in competency gaps can be significant through training. However, assessing performance remained a relatively high weakness among managers.
在当前以市场原则提供卫生服务的模式下,卫生人力能力被认为是实现高质量卫生保健的关键。本研究探讨了公共初级卫生保健管理人员的能力和感知能力差距。
在 2007 年至 2008 年期间,在对六个能力类别进行管理培训之前和之后,对贝尔格莱德初级保健中心的 14 个管理团队进行了询问。通过 Leven、Snedecor 或 Welch 统计分析和学生 t 检验比较两个独立样本,分析了性别、教育水平、经验和职位对能力平均值差异(95%置信区间)的影响。混合模型分析澄清了管理人员基线特征和能力任务评分的可能相互作用。通过方差分析(ANOVA)或 Kruskal-Wallis 检验分析团队评分之间的差异。广义线性模型重复测量分析确定了相互作用和能力差距的变化。差异在 P≤0.05 时具有统计学意义。
女性管理人员在沟通技巧和解决问题方面的培训后,能力水平提高。高层管理人员对评估绩效的重要性评价更高,而首席护士则强调领导的重要性。培训前,评估绩效的能力差距估计普遍最高(6.29),其次是团队建设(5.81)和规划和优先级设置(5.70)。培训五个月后,评估绩效的差距仍然最高,但已大大缩小至 3.18(P<0.0005)。
管理人员将核心能力评为高度重要。通过培训,能力差距的减少可以显著。然而,评估绩效仍然是管理人员相对较高的弱点。