Adejumo A O
Department of Psychology, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria.
Afr J Med Med Sci. 2009 Jun;38 Suppl 2:15-20.
The diagnosis of cancer can devastate the physical, emotional, and socio-economic life of an individual. Caring for most cancer patients presents serious ethical challenges to physicians and other health workers. Inclusion of cancer patients in research could be no less challenging. These ethical problems become significantly magnified in the context of patients who have cancer in a low resource environment characterized by high illiteracy rate, poverty and poor health care infrastructure. Some of the ethical problems include: palliative care and end of life issues, particularly since most patients present in advanced stages, withholding or withdrawal of life support, global equity and justice in drug availability, drug pricing, cancer research and breaking bad news. Adherence to ethical guidelines in conducting cancer research would go a long way in reducing harms and unethical conducts. Similarly, the relevance of clinical and research ethics committees in resolving complex ethical issues in clinical practice has been suggested. However, where these are in place, the need for recourse to philosophical approach, especially virtue ethics in analyzing and resolving ethical concerns in clinical practice cannot be overemphasized. This paper highlights the burden of cancer in Nigeria and the ethical challenges of clinical management of cancer patients, using a case study. The role of clinical ethics and health research ethics committees as well as the justification for virtue ethics above principlism in handling ethical issues in cancer management and research in Nigeria were highlighted.
癌症的诊断会对个人的身体、情感和社会经济生活造成毁灭性影响。照顾大多数癌症患者给医生和其他医护人员带来了严峻的伦理挑战。将癌症患者纳入研究可能同样具有挑战性。在文盲率高、贫困且医疗保健基础设施差的低资源环境中,这些伦理问题在癌症患者的背景下会显著放大。其中一些伦理问题包括:姑息治疗和临终问题,特别是因为大多数患者就诊时已处于晚期,停止或撤销生命支持,药物可及性方面的全球公平与正义、药品定价、癌症研究以及告知坏消息。在开展癌症研究时遵守伦理准则将大大有助于减少危害和不道德行为。同样,有人提出临床和研究伦理委员会在解决临床实践中复杂伦理问题方面的相关性。然而,即便有这些机构,在临床实践中分析和解决伦理问题时诉诸哲学方法,尤其是德性伦理学的必要性再怎么强调也不为过。本文通过一个案例研究,突出了尼日利亚的癌症负担以及癌症患者临床管理中的伦理挑战。强调了临床伦理和健康研究伦理委员会的作用,以及在尼日利亚癌症管理和研究中处理伦理问题时,德性伦理学高于原则主义的合理性。