School of Environmental Sciences, University of Guelph, 350 Stone Rd., East, Guelph, Ontario NIG2W1, Canada.
J Microbiol Methods. 2010 Jun;81(3):259-63. doi: 10.1016/j.mimet.2010.03.015. Epub 2010 Mar 28.
Methods to research the origin of microbial life are limited. However, microorganisms were the first organisms on the Earth capable of cell growth and division, and interactions with their environment, other microbial cells, and eventually with diverse eukaryotic organisms. The origin of microbial life and the supporting scientific evidence are both an enigma and a scientific priority. Numerous hypotheses have been proposed, scenarios imagined, speculations presented in papers, insights shared, and assumptions made without supporting experimentation, which have led to limited progress in understanding the origin of microbial life. The use of the human imagination to envision the origin of life events, without supporting experimentation, observation and independently replicated experiments required for science, is a significant constraint. The challenge remains how to better understand the origin of microbial life using observations and experimental methods as opposed to speculation, assumptions, scenarios, envisioning events and un-testable hypotheses. This is not an easy challenge as experimental design and plausible hypothesis testing are difficult. Since past approaches have been inconclusive in providing evidence for the origin of microbial life mechanisms and the manner in which genetic instructions was encoded into DNA/RNA, it is reasonable and logical to propose that progress will be made when testable, plausible hypotheses and methods are used in the origin of microbial life research, and the experimental observations are, or are not reproduced in independent laboratories. These perspectives will be discussed in this article as well as the possibility that a pre-biotic film preceded a microbial biofilm as a possible micro-location for the origin of microbial cells capable of growth and division.
研究微生物生命起源的方法有限。然而,微生物是地球上第一批能够进行细胞生长和分裂,并与环境、其他微生物细胞以及最终与各种真核生物相互作用的生物体。微生物生命的起源及其支持的科学证据既是一个谜,也是一个科学优先事项。已经提出了许多假说,想象了场景,在论文中提出了推测,分享了见解,并做出了假设,而没有支持实验,这导致对微生物生命起源的理解进展有限。在没有支持实验、观察和科学所需的可重复实验的情况下,仅仅依靠人类想象力来设想生命起源事件,是一个重大的限制。挑战仍然是如何使用观察和实验方法来更好地理解微生物生命的起源,而不是推测、假设、场景、设想事件和不可检验的假说。这不是一个容易的挑战,因为实验设计和合理的假说检验都很困难。由于过去的方法在提供微生物生命机制起源的证据以及遗传指令如何编码到 DNA/RNA 方面都没有得出结论,因此合理的逻辑是,当在微生物生命起源研究中使用可检验的、合理的假说和方法,并在独立实验室中复制或不复制实验观察时,将会取得进展。本文将讨论这些观点,以及前生物膜可能先于微生物生物膜出现的可能性,这可能是能够生长和分裂的微生物细胞起源的一个微位置。