Casey V A, Dwyer J T, Berkey C S, Coleman K A, Gardner J, Valadian I
Tufts University, School of Nutrition, Medford, MA.
Am J Clin Nutr. 1991 Jun;53(6):1493-8. doi: 10.1093/ajcn/53.6.1493.
Recalled body weight and self-reported current weight were validated in a longitudinal study population by comparing recalls at 50 y to actual measures taken at ages 18, 30, 40, and 50 y. Recalled body weights were also compared with reported desired weights at these same ages. Self-reported weights at 50 y were equally accurate for both males and females; the mean reporting underestimate was -1.98 kg for males and -1.86 kg for females. Males' self reports at age 50 y were influenced by years of education (P less than 0.005) and current body size (P less than 0.0001) whereas females' were not. Correlations between recall of past weights and measured weights ranged from r = 0.87 at 18 y to 0.95 at 40 y. Recalls of past body weight were not significantly influenced by the passage of time, the number of years of education, or the accuracy of current weight reports. Current body size (wt/ht2) was significantly associated with life-time weight dissatisfaction in both sexes (P less than 0.0005).
在一项纵向研究人群中,通过比较50岁时的回忆体重与18岁、30岁、40岁和50岁时实际测量的体重,对回忆的体重和自我报告的当前体重进行了验证。还将回忆的体重与这些相同年龄时报告的理想体重进行了比较。50岁时自我报告的体重对男性和女性同样准确;男性报告低估的平均体重为-1.98千克,女性为-1.86千克。50岁男性的自我报告受教育年限(P<0.005)和当前体型(P<0.0001)的影响,而女性则不受影响。过去体重回忆与测量体重之间的相关性范围从18岁时的r = 0.87到40岁时的0.95。过去体重的回忆不受时间推移、受教育年限或当前体重报告准确性的显著影响。当前体型(体重/身高²)与两性终生体重不满显著相关(P<0.0005)。