Dhillon M
Queen's University Kingston, Ontario, Canada.
Ann Allergy. 1991 May;66(5):385-92.
There is evidence to suggest that molds can cause IgE-mediated upper respiratory tract disorders and immunotherapy is efficacious in a select group. The environmental sampling studies show a remarkably small numbers of molds accounting for a majority of the mold load in various diverse locations. These are Cladosporium, Basidiospores, Aspergillus, and Alternaria-Penicillin families. Basidiospores have been underreported in the older studies because of difficulties in their identification. Whether the absolute mold level is the most important factor leading to IgE formation and induction of upper respiratory tract symptoms is uncertain. Certainly, the majority of the studies are based on the assumption that the absolute level of mold in the environment is the most important factor leading to the development of symptoms, but this is not based on strong evidence. A major problem in the majority of the studies is a lack of standardization of extracts which may lead to false negatives on skin testing and thus produce variable data in population evaluations comparing the prevalence of mold to its ability to induce IgE production and symptoms. The best current trials to document the efficacy of mold immunotherapy have been with the standardized Cladosporium extract. Unfortunately, these results cannot be extrapolated to the commercially available mold extracts available in the United States either for immunotherapy or for skin testing. These extracts are highly variable in their potency, prone to high false negative rates, and at best serve as poor skin testing reagents and possibly even worse immunotherapy reagents. Adequately standardized mold reagents are urgently needed to determine whether the Cladosporium data can be extrapolated to them in any meaningful way.
有证据表明,霉菌可导致IgE介导的上呼吸道疾病,免疫疗法对特定人群有效。环境采样研究表明,在不同地点,数量极少的几种霉菌占霉菌总量的大部分。这些霉菌是枝孢属、担子孢子、曲霉属和链格孢-青霉科。由于担子孢子鉴定困难,在以往的研究中对其报道较少。绝对霉菌水平是否是导致IgE形成和诱发上呼吸道症状的最重要因素尚不确定。当然,大多数研究基于这样的假设,即环境中霉菌的绝对水平是导致症状出现的最重要因素,但这并无确凿证据支持。大多数研究中的一个主要问题是提取物缺乏标准化,这可能导致皮肤试验出现假阴性结果,从而在比较霉菌患病率与其诱导IgE产生及症状能力的人群评估中产生可变数据。目前证明霉菌免疫疗法有效性的最佳试验是使用标准化的枝孢属提取物。不幸的是,这些结果既不能外推至美国市场上用于免疫疗法或皮肤试验的市售霉菌提取物。这些提取物的效力差异很大,假阴性率高,充其量只能作为劣质的皮肤试验试剂,甚至可能是更差的免疫疗法试剂。迫切需要充分标准化的霉菌试剂,以确定枝孢属的数据是否能以任何有意义的方式外推至它们。