Institute of Thermal and Environmental Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai, PR China.
Waste Manag Res. 2010 Jun;28(6):508-19. doi: 10.1177/0734242X10361761. Epub 2010 Apr 7.
The environmental profile of two municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) technologies with semi-dry flue gas cleaning, namely grated firing incinerators (GFI) and fluidised bed incinerators (FBI) that are commonly used in China were evaluated and compared by life-cycle assessment (LCA) using the EASEWASTE model. All emissions of key pollutants as well as energy, resource and material inputs and outputs associated with the two MSWI technologies were determined and the corresponding environmental impact potentials were modelled. Incineration of MSW with a lower heating value (LHV) around 4.5 MJ kg(-1) demands that auxiliary fuel is used, and both GFI and FBI caused environmental loads by contributing with environmental impact potentials in most categories except for some saving in global warming (GW100) and hazardous waste (HW). Coal combustion in FBI is a main contributor to the environmental impact potentials and thus should always be limited to a minimum. Auxiliary fuels can be avoided when the LHV of MSW is higher than 5-6 MJ kg(- 1). For all scenarios, GFI saves more global warming potentials than FBI due to its higher net power generation from combustion of MSW itself. Leachate from the bunker could be sprayed into the furnace for evaporation under high temperature, as an alternative to waste-water treatment, without major changes in the environmental profile of the incinerator. The presented evaluations may contribute to a more balanced environmental assessment of the two incineration technologies with respect to incineration of MSW with low heating values as often found in Asia and China.
采用 EASEWASTE 模型,通过生命周期评价(LCA)对两种常用于中国的具有半干法烟气净化的城市固体废物焚烧(MSWI)技术,即炉排焚烧炉(GFI)和流化床焚烧炉(FBI)的环境状况进行了评估和比较。确定了与这两种 MSWI 技术相关的所有关键污染物排放以及能源、资源和材料投入和产出,并对相应的环境影响潜力进行了建模。焚烧低热值(LHV)约为 4.5MJ/kg 的 MSW 需要使用辅助燃料,GFI 和 FBI 除了在一些全球变暖(GW100)和危险废物(HW)方面有节约外,在大多数类别中都会造成环境负荷和环境影响潜力。FBI 中的煤炭燃烧是造成环境影响潜力的主要因素,因此应始终将其限制在最低水平。当 MSW 的 LHV 高于 5-6MJ/kg 时,可以避免使用辅助燃料。对于所有情景,由于 GFI 本身燃烧 MSW 产生的净发电量更高,因此其产生的全球变暖潜力比 FBI 少。可以将煤仓中的渗滤液喷入高温炉膛进行蒸发,作为废水处理的替代方法,而不会对焚烧炉的环境状况产生重大影响。所进行的评估可能有助于对两种焚烧技术进行更平衡的环境评估,因为亚洲和中国经常发现低热值 MSW 的焚烧。