Health Effects Laboratory Division, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Morgantown, West Virginia 26505-2888, USA.
Chem Res Toxicol. 2010 May 17;23(5):918-25. doi: 10.1021/tx100003w.
The need for alternatives to animal-based skin sensitization testing has spurred research on the use of in vitro, in silico, and in chemico methods. Glutathione and other select peptides have been used to determine the reactivity of electrophilic allergens to nucleophiles, but these methods are inadequate to accurately measure rapid kinetics observed with many chemical sensitizers. A kinetic spectrophotometric assay involving the reactivity of electrophilic sensitizers to nitrobenzenethiol was evaluated. Stopped-flow techniques and conventional UV spectrophotometric measurements enabled the determination of reaction rates with half-lives ranging from 0.4 ms (benzoquinone) to 46.2 s (ethyl acrylate). Rate constants were measured for seven extreme, five strong, seven moderate, and four weak/nonsensitizers. Seventeen out of the 23 tested chemicals were pseudo-first order, and three were second order. In three out of the 23 chemicals, deviations from first and second order were apparent where the chemicals exhibited complex kinetics whose rates are mixed order. The reaction rates of the electrophiles correlated positively with their EC3 values within the same mechanistic domain. Nonsensitizers such as benzaldehyde, sodium lauryl sulfate, and benzocaine did not react with nitrobenzenethiol. Cyclic anhydrides, select diones, and aromatic aldehydes proved to be false negatives in this assay. The findings from this simple and rapid absorbance model show that for the same mechanistic domain, skin sensitization is driven mainly by electrophilic reactivity. This simple, rapid, and inexpensive absorbance-based method has great potential for use as a preliminary screening tool for skin allergens.
替代基于动物的皮肤致敏测试的需求促使人们研究使用体外、计算和化学方法。谷胱甘肽和其他选择的肽已被用于确定亲电变应原对亲核试剂的反应性,但这些方法不足以准确测量许多化学敏化剂的快速动力学。评估了涉及亲电敏化剂与硝基苯硫醇反应性的动力学分光光度测定法。停流技术和常规紫外分光光度测量使半衰期范围从 0.4 毫秒(苯醌)到 46.2 秒(丙烯酸乙酯)的反应速率得以确定。测量了七种极端、五种强、七种中等和四种弱/非敏化剂的速率常数。在所测试的 23 种化学物质中有 17 种是准一级,有 3 种是二级。在 23 种化学物质中的 3 种中,一级和二级的偏差明显,其中化学物质表现出混合顺序的复杂动力学。亲电试剂的反应速率与其在同一机械域中的 EC3 值呈正相关。像苯甲醛、十二烷基硫酸钠和苯佐卡因这样的非敏化剂不会与硝基苯硫醇反应。环状酐、某些二酮和芳香醛在该测定中被证明是假阴性。这个简单而快速的吸光度模型的发现表明,在相同的机械域中,皮肤致敏主要是由亲电性决定的。这种简单、快速且廉价的基于吸光度的方法具有作为皮肤变应原初步筛选工具的巨大潜力。