Ross Ann H, Williams Shanna E
Department of Sociology and Anthropology, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina 27695-8107, USA.
J Craniofac Surg. 2010 Mar;21(2):458-61. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0b013e3181cfea34.
Despite the attainment of several adult cranial dimensions relatively early in childhood, skeletal maturity and, by consequence, adult form are typically defined by the eruption of the third molars around 17 years of age. This in turn serves as the division between subadults and adults, which is then applied to population studies of biological variation. Specifically, comparative data sets of adult measurements are not directly applied to individuals who do not have complete skeletal growth, as it is believed that the confounding effects of allometry may skew the results. The present study uses geometric morphometrics techniques to investigate the appropriateness of this division with respect to three-dimensional anatomical landmarks. Twenty-six landmarks were collected from a single population of 24 crania partitioned into 4 age groups spanning late adolescence to midadulthood. Generalized Procrustes and multivariate statistical analyses were performed on the landmark data. Results showed no significant morphological differences between the teen and young adult age groups, whereas significant shape and size differences were found in older adults relative to their younger cohorts. Moreover, no growth-related shape variation (ie, allometry) was detected within the sample. These findings suggest that adult form is attained several years earlier than commonly thought and corroborate other research that suggest that subtle changes in cranial morphology continue throughout adulthood.
尽管儿童期相对较早地达到了几个成人颅骨尺寸,但骨骼成熟度以及随之而来的成人形态通常由17岁左右第三磨牙的萌出来定义。这反过来又成为亚成年人和成年人之间的划分依据,并应用于生物变异的群体研究。具体而言,成人测量的比较数据集不会直接应用于骨骼生长未完全完成的个体,因为人们认为异速生长的混杂效应可能会扭曲结果。本研究使用几何形态计量学技术,针对三维解剖标志点来研究这种划分的合理性。从一个由24个颅骨组成的单一群体中收集了26个标志点,该群体被划分为4个年龄组,涵盖了青春期后期到成年中期。对标志点数据进行了广义普氏分析和多变量统计分析。结果显示,青少年和青年成人年龄组之间没有显著的形态差异,而相对于较年轻的同龄人,老年人存在显著的形状和大小差异。此外,样本中未检测到与生长相关的形状变化(即异速生长)。这些发现表明,成人形态的达成比通常认为的要早几年,并证实了其他研究结果,即颅骨形态的细微变化在整个成年期都会持续。