Department of Medical Sociology, University of Duesseldorf, Germany.
New England Research Institutes, Inc, Health Services and Disparities Research, 9 Galen Street, Watertown, MA 02472, United States.
Soc Sci Med. 2010 Jul;71(2):298-304. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2010.03.043. Epub 2010 Apr 28.
Work-related stress among physicians has been an issue of growing concern in recent years. How and why this may vary between different health care systems remains poorly understood. Using an established theoretical model (effort-reward imbalance), this study analyses levels of work stress among primary care physicians (PCPs) in three different health care systems, the United States, the United Kingdom and Germany. Whether professional autonomy and specific features of the work environment are associated with work stress and account for possible country differences are examined. Data are derived from self-administered questionnaires obtained from 640 randomly sampled physicians recruited for an international comparative study of medical decision making conducted from 2005 to 2007. Results demonstrate country-specific differences in work stress with the highest level in Germany, intermediate level in the US and lowest level among UK physicians. A negative correlation between professional autonomy and work stress is observed in all three countries, but neither this association nor features of the work environment account for the observed country differences. Whether there will be adequate numbers of PCPs, or even a field of primary care in the future, is of increasing concern in several countries. To the extent that work-related stress contributes to this, identification of its organizational correlates in different health care systems may offer opportunities for remedial interventions.
近年来,与工作相关的压力一直是医生们越来越关注的问题。这种压力在不同的医疗体系中是如何产生的,以及为什么会有所不同,目前仍不甚了解。本研究运用成熟的理论模型(工作压力与回报失衡),分析了美国、英国和德国三个不同医疗体系中初级保健医生(PCP)的工作压力水平。研究还探讨了职业自主性和工作环境的具体特征是否与工作压力有关,以及是否可以解释可能存在的国家差异。本研究的数据来自于 2005 年至 2007 年期间进行的一项国际医学决策比较研究中,从 640 名随机抽样的医生中收集的自填式问卷。结果表明,工作压力存在国家差异,德国的工作压力最高,美国居中,英国医生的工作压力最低。在这三个国家中,职业自主性与工作压力呈负相关,但这种关联以及工作环境的特征都无法解释观察到的国家差异。在一些国家,未来是否有足够数量的 PCP 甚至是否存在初级保健领域,正成为越来越令人担忧的问题。如果工作相关的压力对此有影响,那么在不同的医疗体系中确定其组织相关性,可能为补救干预提供机会。