Department of Ophthalmology, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York, NY, USA.
Eye (Lond). 2010 Oct;24(10):1555-60. doi: 10.1038/eye.2010.83. Epub 2010 May 28.
To compare agreement of intraocular pressure (IOP) measurements using Goldmann applanation tonometry (GAT) and Goldmann correlated intraocular pressure generated (IOPg) by the Reichert ocular response analyser (ORA).
Consecutive patients presenting for glaucoma evaluation underwent ORA assessment followed by examination including GAT. For each ORA assessment, measurements were taken until a waveform score (WS) of 6.5 was obtained or until five measurements were obtained per eye. The relationship between GAT and IOPg and the influence of the WS upon this relationship was evaluated. A Bland-Altman plot and linear regression were used to determine agreement between GAT and IOPg.
A total of 518 eyes of 260 patients were included in the final analysis. Increasing WS was found to predict a smaller difference between GAT and IOPg (β=-0.2, P≤0.001). Selecting the highest WS among ORA assessments of each eye, WS continued to predict concordance between GAT and IOPg (β=-0.2, P=0.006). The mean IOP difference between methods was 0.1 mm Hg (±0.3), which was found to be statistically insignificant (P=0.391). This relationship between GAT and IOPg was successfully validated using a second distinct data set of 100 eyes. GAT and IOPg measurements varied by 2 mm Hg or less in 53.9% of eyes and 5 mm Hg or less in 92.3% of eyes.
In clinical practice IOPg is strongly related to GAT. Although higher WS is indicative of greater IOPg/GAT concordance, its influence is minimal. This study does not support the use of a specific WS cutoff to determine quality of an IOPg measurement.
比较 Goldmann 压平眼压计(GAT)和 Reichert 眼前节分析仪(ORA)产生的 Goldmann 相关眼压(IOPg)测量值的一致性。
连续就诊的青光眼患者行 ORA 评估,然后进行检查,包括 GAT。对于每个 ORA 评估,测量值直到获得 6.5 分的波形评分(WS),或每只眼获得 5 次测量值为止。评估 GAT 与 IOPg 之间的关系,以及 WS 对这种关系的影响。使用 Bland-Altman 图和线性回归来确定 GAT 和 IOPg 之间的一致性。
共纳入 260 例患者的 518 只眼进行最终分析。发现随着 WS 的增加,GAT 和 IOPg 之间的差异预测值变小(β=-0.2,P≤0.001)。在每只眼的 ORA 评估中选择最高的 WS,WS 仍然可以预测 GAT 和 IOPg 之间的一致性(β=-0.2,P=0.006)。两种方法之间的平均眼压差值为 0.1mmHg(±0.3),差异无统计学意义(P=0.391)。该关系使用第二组 100 只眼的独立数据集进行了成功验证。在 53.9%的眼中,GAT 和 IOPg 测量值差异为 2mmHg 或更小,在 92.3%的眼中差异为 5mmHg 或更小。
在临床实践中,IOPg 与 GAT 密切相关。尽管较高的 WS 表明 IOPg/GAT 一致性更高,但影响很小。本研究不支持使用特定的 WS 截止值来确定 IOPg 测量值的质量。