Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
J Rheumatol. 2010 Jul;37(7):1422-30. doi: 10.3899/jrheum.090978. Epub 2010 Jun 1.
To develop recommendations for the use of methotrexate (MTX) in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.
Canadian rheumatologists who participated in the international 3e Initiative in Rheumatology (evidence, expertise, exchange) in 2007-2008 formulated 5 unique Canadian questions. A bibliographic team systematically reviewed the relevant literature on these 5 topics. An expert committee consisting of 26 rheumatologists from across Canada was convened, and a set of recommendations was proposed based on the results of systematic reviews combined with expert opinions using a nominal group consensus process.
The 5 questions addressed drug interactions, predictors of response, strategies to reduce non-serious side effects, variables to assess clinical response, and incorporating patient preference into decision-making. The systematic review retrieved 93 pertinent articles; this evidence was presented to the expert committee during the interactive workshop. After extensive discussion and voting, a total of 9 recommendations were formulated: 2 on drug interactions, 1 on predictors of response, 2 on strategies to reduce non-serious side effects, 3 on variables to assess clinical response, and 1 on incorporating patient preferences into decision-making. The level of evidence and the strength of recommendations are reported. Agreement among panelists ranged from 85% to 100%.
Nine recommendations pertaining to the use of MTX in daily practice were developed using an evidence-based approach followed by expert/physician consensus with high level of agreement.
为类风湿关节炎患者制定甲氨蝶呤(MTX)使用建议。
2007-2008 年参与国际 3e 倡议(循证、专业知识、交流)的加拿大风湿病学家制定了 5 个独特的加拿大问题。一个文献团队系统地回顾了这些 5 个主题的相关文献。召集了一个由来自加拿大各地的 26 名风湿病专家组成的专家委员会,根据系统评价的结果结合专家意见,使用名义小组共识过程提出了一套建议。
这 5 个问题涉及药物相互作用、反应预测、减少非严重副作用的策略、评估临床反应的变量以及将患者偏好纳入决策。系统评价检索到 93 篇相关文章;该证据在互动研讨会上提交给专家委员会。经过广泛的讨论和投票,共制定了 9 项建议:2 项关于药物相互作用,1 项关于反应预测,2 项关于减少非严重副作用的策略,3 项关于评估临床反应的变量,1 项关于将患者偏好纳入决策。报告了证据水平和建议强度。小组成员之间的一致性从 85%到 100%不等。
使用循证方法制定了 9 项关于 MTX 在日常实践中使用的建议,然后通过专家/医生共识达成高度一致。