Department of Cariology, Academic Centre for Dentistry Amsterdam (ACTA), University of Amsterdam and VU University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Caries Res. 2010;44(3):260-6. doi: 10.1159/000314673. Epub 2010 May 27.
It is often claimed that 3 fluoride moments a day significantly reduce the caries risk compared to 2 daily fluoride moments. However, previous research is not conclusive. Therefore, the aim of this study was to compare the effect on lesion progression of 2 versus 3 fluoride moments a day. A double-blind, randomized, cross-over in situ experiment was designed. The experiment comprised 2 in situ periods of 3 weeks with a washout period of 3 weeks in between. Sixteen participants wore an enamel and a dentine specimen with a preformed lesion placed buccally in their partial prosthesis. The participants brushed twice a day with a 1,400 ppm F (amine fluoride) toothpaste and rinsed once a day with either 250 ppm F (amine F/NaF) or a placebo rinse. At the end of the experiment the specimens were retrieved for fluoride analysis and the assessment of integrated mineral loss with transversal microradiography. The fluoride analysis showed a statistically significant increase in structurally bound fluoride in dentine, but not in enamel, when comparing the fluoride mouthrinse group with the placebo rinse group. The amounts of loosely bound, KOH-soluble fluoride were not different between both groups neither for enamel nor for dentine. In dentine IML gain was significantly (p < 0.05) higher for the fluoride mouthrinse group than for the placebo mouthrinse group. In enamel no statistically significant differences in IML gain were found. For dentine a third fluoride moment may be beneficial in enhancing remineralisation, even under the remineralising conditions as in this study.
人们常说,与每天两次的氟化物使用相比,每天三次使用氟化物能显著降低龋齿风险。然而,之前的研究结果并不确定。因此,本研究旨在比较每天两次与三次氟化物使用对牙釉质龋损进展的影响。本研究采用双盲、随机、交叉的在体实验设计。实验包括两个为期 3 周的在体期和一个为期 3 周的洗脱期。16 名参与者佩戴一个牙釉质和牙本质样本,在其局部义齿的颊侧有一个预先形成的龋损。参与者每天刷牙两次,使用含 1400ppmF(胺氟化物)的牙膏,每天漱口一次,使用 250ppmF(胺 F/NaF)或安慰剂漱口液。实验结束时,取出标本进行氟化物分析和横切显微放射照相评估整合矿物质损失。氟化物分析显示,与安慰剂漱口液组相比,氟化物漱口液组牙本质中的结构结合氟有统计学意义的增加,但牙釉质中没有。两组的松散结合、KOH 可溶氟含量在牙釉质和牙本质中均无差异。牙本质中,氟化物漱口液组的 IML 增加明显(p < 0.05)高于安慰剂漱口液组。牙釉质中 IML 增加无统计学差异。对于牙本质,在本研究的再矿化条件下,增加第三次氟化物使用可能有利于增强再矿化。