Department of Medical Education, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60612, USA.
Acad Med. 2010 May;85(5):837-43. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e3181d74562.
The authors explore issues surrounding digital repositories with the twofold intention of clarifying their creation, structure, content, and use, and considering the implementation of a global digital repository for medical education research data sets-an online site where medical education researchers would be encouraged to deposit their data in order to facilitate the reuse and reanalysis of the data by other researchers. By motivating data sharing and reuse, investigators, medical schools, and other stakeholders might see substantial benefits to their own endeavors and to the progress of the field of medical education.The authors review digital repositories in medicine, social sciences, and education, describe the contents and scope of repositories, and present extant examples. The authors describe the potential benefits of a medical education data repository and report results of a survey of the Society for Directors of Research in Medicine Education, in which participants responded to questions about data sharing and a potential data repository. Respondents strongly endorsed data sharing, with the caveat that principal investigators should choose whether or not to share data they collect. A large majority believed that a repository would benefit their unit and the field of medical education. Few reported using existing repositories. Finally, the authors consider challenges to the establishment of such a repository, including taxonomic organization, intellectual property concerns, human subjects protection, technological infrastructure, and evaluation standards. The authors conclude with recommendations for how a medical education data repository could be successfully developed.
作者探讨了数字资源库的问题,旨在阐明其创建、结构、内容和用途,并考虑建立一个全球医学教育研究数据集数字资源库——一个在线站点,鼓励医学教育研究人员在此存储其数据,以便其他研究人员能够方便地重复使用和重新分析这些数据。通过激励数据共享和重复使用,研究人员、医学院校和其他利益相关者可能会从自身努力和医学教育领域的发展中获得实质性的收益。
作者回顾了医学、社会科学和教育领域的数字资源库,描述了资源库的内容和范围,并介绍了现有的示例。作者描述了医学教育数据资源库的潜在益处,并报告了对医学教育研究主任学会的一项调查结果,参与者对数据共享和潜在的数据资源库的问题做出了回应。受访者强烈支持数据共享,但前提是主要研究者应该选择是否共享他们收集的数据。绝大多数人认为资源库将使他们的单位和医学教育领域受益。很少有人报告使用现有的资源库。最后,作者考虑了建立这样一个资源库所面临的挑战,包括分类组织、知识产权问题、保护人类受试者、技术基础设施和评估标准。作者最后提出了如何成功开发医学教育数据资源库的建议。