Montreal Children's Hospital, Montreal, QC.
Can J Public Health. 2010 Mar-Apr;101(2):115-8. doi: 10.1007/BF03404354.
To determine whether a sharp increase in Emergency Room (ER) visits at the Montreal Children's Hospital (MCH) during the week following the death of Natasha Richardson from a skiing-related head injury was a) statistically significant and b) related to media coverage of the event. We postulated that there would be less coverage in the French media and in centres west of Quebec.
We compared the number of visits to the MCH ER for 10 weeks beginning March 5 and recorded the number for head-related injuries. These data were also compared with averages for the MCH for the same weeks in the previous 16 years; with visit figures from Hôpital Ste-Justine (HSJ); and with those from 3 other pediatric hospitals in provinces west of Quebec for the same period.
We found a 60% increase in injury visits to the MCH ER compared to the baseline week (p < 0.001) and a 66% difference when compared with the 16-year average. HSJ also recorded a sharp increase during the study week but the rise did not persist. Smaller increases were recorded in the more western children's hospitals. At the MCH nearly half of the visits were for head injuries, but there was no change in the number judged to be severe.
These data suggest that the media coverage of this celebrity death may have generated anxiety among parents, prompting those who might not otherwise have sought medical care to bring their children to the ER.
确定在蒙特利尔儿童医院(MCH)因与滑雪相关的头部受伤而导致 Natasha Richardson 死亡后的一周内,急诊室(ER)就诊人数的急剧增加是否 a)具有统计学意义,b)与该事件的媒体报道有关。我们假设法语媒体和魁北克以西的中心的报道会较少。
我们比较了从 3 月 5 日开始的 10 周内前往 MCH ER 的就诊次数,并记录了与头部相关的受伤次数。这些数据还与 MCH 在过去 16 年同期的平均值进行了比较;与 Sainte-Justine 医院(HSJ)的就诊数据进行了比较;并与魁北克以西的其他 3 家儿童医院在同一时期的数据进行了比较。
与基线周相比,我们发现 MCH ER 的伤害就诊人数增加了 60%(p < 0.001),与 16 年的平均值相比增加了 66%。HSJ 在研究周内也记录到了急剧增加,但这种增长并未持续。在更西部的儿童医院,记录到的增幅较小。在 MCH,近一半的就诊是头部受伤,但被认为严重的受伤人数没有变化。
这些数据表明,对这位名人死亡的媒体报道可能引起了父母的焦虑,促使那些原本可能不会寻求医疗护理的人带孩子去急诊室。