Center for Adolescent and Family Studies, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47401, USA.
J Fam Psychol. 2010 Jun;24(3):339-48. doi: 10.1037/a0019406.
The study examined the effectiveness of Functional Family Therapy (FFT), as compared to probation services, in a community juvenile justice setting 12 months posttreatment. The study also provides specific insight into the interactive effects of therapist model specific adherence and measures of youth risk and protective factors on behavioral outcomes for a diverse group of adolescents. The findings suggest that FFT was effective in reducing youth behavioral problems, although only when the therapists adhered to the treatment model. High-adherent therapists delivering FFT had a statistically significant reduction of (35%) in felony, a (30%) violent crime, and a marginally significant reduction (21%) in misdemeanor recidivisms, as compared to the control condition. The results represent a significant reduction in serious crimes 1 year after treatment, when delivered by a model adherent therapist. The low-adherent therapists were significantly higher than the control group in recidivism rates. There was an interaction effect between youth risk level and therapist adherence demonstrating that the most difficult families (those with high peer and family risk) had a higher likelihood of successful outcomes when their therapist demonstrated model-specific adherence. These results are discussed within the context of the need and importance of measuring and accounting for model specific adherence in the evaluation of community-based replications of evidence-based family therapy models like FFT.
该研究考察了功能家庭治疗(FFT)与缓刑服务相比在社区少年司法环境中的治疗后 12 个月的效果。该研究还提供了具体的见解,了解治疗师模型特定的坚持程度和青年风险和保护因素的衡量标准对各种青少年行为结果的交互作用。研究结果表明,FFT 可有效减少青少年的行为问题,但前提是治疗师要坚持治疗模式。高坚持度的治疗师提供的 FFT 可使重罪(减少 35%)、暴力犯罪(减少 30%)和轻微犯罪(减少 21%)的累犯率出现统计学显著降低,与对照组相比。与对照组相比,治疗师坚持模型的情况下,FFT 治疗 1 年后严重犯罪的减少具有显著意义。低坚持度的治疗师的累犯率明显高于对照组。青少年风险水平与治疗师坚持程度之间存在交互作用,表明当治疗师表现出特定模式的坚持时,最困难的家庭(那些具有高同伴和家庭风险的家庭)有更高的成功可能性。这些结果在需要和重视衡量和解释基于证据的家庭治疗模式(如 FFT)的社区复制中,治疗师的特定模式坚持程度的背景下进行了讨论。