Department of Public Health and Primary Care, University of Cambridge School of Clinical Medicine, Institute of Public Health, Robinson Way, Forvie Site, Cambridge CB2 0SR, UK.
J Public Health (Oxf). 2011 Jun;33(2):272-9. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdq048. Epub 2010 Jun 16.
Little attention has been paid on the carbon footprint of different healthcare service models. We examined this question for service models for patients with acute ST elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI).
We estimated carbon emissions associated with ambulance (patient) transport under a primary percutaneous coronary intervention (pPCI) care model based in tertiary centres, compared with historical emissions under a thrombolysis model based in general hospitals. We used geographical information on 41,449 hospitalizations, and published UK government fuel to carbon emissions conversion factors.
The average ambulance journey required for transporting a STEMI patient to its closest care point was 13.0 km under the thrombolysis model and 42.2 km under the pPCI model, producing 3.46 and 11.2 kg of CO(2) emissions, respectively. Thus, introducing pPCI will more than triple ambulance journey associated carbon emissions (by a factor of 3.24). This ratio was robust to sensitivity analysis varying assumptions on conversion factor values; and the number of patients treated.
Introducing pPCI to manage STEMI patients results in substantial carbon emissions increase. Environmental profiling of service modernization projects could motivate carbon control strategies, and care pathways design that will reduce patient transport need. Healthcare planners should consider the environmental legacy of quality improvement initiatives.
人们对不同医疗服务模式的碳足迹关注甚少。我们考察了急性 ST 段抬高型心肌梗死(STEMI)患者的服务模式。
我们根据基于三级医院的直接经皮冠状动脉介入治疗(pPCI)护理模式,估计了与救护车(患者)转运相关的碳排放,与基于综合医院的溶栓治疗模式相比,该模式具有历史意义。我们使用了 41449 例住院患者的地理位置信息和英国政府公布的燃料至碳排放量转换系数。
在溶栓模型下,将 STEMI 患者转运至最近的治疗点的平均救护车行程为 13.0 公里,而在 pPCI 模型下为 42.2 公里,分别产生 3.46 和 11.2 千克的 CO2 排放量。因此,引入 pPCI 将使救护车相关碳排放量增加两倍以上(增加 3.24 倍)。该比值对转换系数值的敏感性分析和治疗患者数量的变化具有稳健性。
引入 pPCI 治疗 STEMI 患者会导致大量碳排放增加。服务现代化项目的环境概况分析可以激励碳控制策略和减少患者转运需求的护理路径设计。医疗保健规划者应考虑质量改进计划的环境遗留问题。