De Col P, Baron C, Guillaumin C, Bouquet E, Fanello S
UFR de médecine, département de médecine générale, 4, rue Larrey, 49045 Angers cedex 1, France.
Rev Mal Respir. 2010 May;27(5):431-40. doi: 10.1016/j.rmr.2010.03.001.
Smoking among doctors would be an obstacle to effective smoking prevention, in particular the practice of minimal advice.
To assess the smoking habits of general practitioners (GPs) in the department of Maine-et-Loire and to study the link between their smoking status and their practice of minimal smoking cessation advice in 2008 in a legislative context unfavourable to smokers.
Three hundred and thirty-two GPs in the department of Maine-et-Loire answered a survey (response rate: 60%) investigating their own smoking habits and how they approach patients who smoke.
The prevalence of active smoking among general practitioners responders was 18%, 34% were former smokers and 47% had never smoked. Regular smokers (10%) smoked on average 14 cigarettes a day and 51% were nicotine dependent (9% strongly). When consulting, 32% of doctors systematically addressed smoking habits, 20% said that they gave minimal smoking cessation advice regardless of their smoking status. Doctors who smoked were less prone to ask their patients if they smoke (p=0.002) and they believed that their smoking does not influence their practice of giving minimal smoking advice. Moreover, the incentive and coercive measures introduced in 2006 had no influence on the smoking status of physicians, but allowed them to speak more frequently about smoking to their patients.
Minimal smoking cessation advice is applied systematically by only 20% of physicians regardless of their smoking status. Non-systematic smoking cessation advice benefited from the measures introduced in 2006.
医生吸烟会成为有效预防吸烟的障碍,尤其是提供最低限度建议的做法。
评估曼恩-卢瓦尔省全科医生的吸烟习惯,并研究在2008年不利于吸烟者的立法背景下,他们的吸烟状况与提供最低限度戒烟建议的做法之间的联系。
曼恩-卢瓦尔省的332名全科医生回答了一项调查(回复率:60%),该调查询问了他们自己的吸烟习惯以及他们如何对待吸烟的患者。
回复调查的全科医生中,现吸烟者的患病率为18%,34%为曾经吸烟者,47%从未吸烟。经常吸烟者(10%)平均每天吸14支烟,51%对尼古丁有依赖(9%为强烈依赖)。在诊疗时,32%的医生会系统地询问吸烟习惯,20%表示无论自己的吸烟状况如何,都会提供最低限度的戒烟建议。吸烟的医生不太倾向于询问患者是否吸烟(p=0.002),并且他们认为自己吸烟并不影响提供最低限度戒烟建议的做法。此外,2006年出台的激励和强制措施对医生的吸烟状况没有影响,但使他们更频繁地与患者谈论吸烟问题。
无论吸烟状况如何,只有20%的医生会系统地提供最低限度的戒烟建议。非系统性的戒烟建议受益于2006年出台的措施。