Multisensory Perception Lab, Department of Psychology, Neuroscience & Behaviour, McMaster University, 1280 Main Street West, Hamilton, Ontario, L8S 4K1, Canada.
Exp Brain Res. 2010 Jul;204(3):431-46. doi: 10.1007/s00221-010-2268-5. Epub 2010 Jun 24.
A conflict between an egocentric and an external reference frame can be highlighted by examining the marked deficit observed with tactile temporal order judgments (TOJ) when the hands are crossed. The anecdotally-reported large individual differences in the magnitude of this crossed-hands deficit were explored here by testing a large group of participants (48; 24 female). Given that females have been shown to be more visually dependent than males in the potentially related rod-and-frame test (RFT), we hypothesized that females would show a larger influence of the external reference frame (i.e., a larger crossed-hands deficit). As predicted, female participants produced larger tactile TOJ deficits compared to our male participants. We also administered the RFT in these participants with hands crossed and uncrossed. Crossing the hands increased the effect of the frame in the RFT, more so for females than males, further highlighting the potential difference in the way that each sex accommodates reference frame conflicts. Finally, examining the relation between the two tasks revealed a significant correlation, with larger frame effects associated with larger crossed-hands TOJ deficits, but this only held for males. We speculate that sex-specific differences in multisensory processing and spatial ability may explain why females are less able to disambiguate a crossed-hands posture than are males.
当双手交叉时,触觉时间顺序判断 (TOJ) 会出现明显的偏差,这种偏差可以突出自我中心和外部参照系之间的冲突。通过测试一大群参与者(48 人;24 名女性),我们探索了这种交叉手偏差幅度的个体差异很大的现象。由于女性在潜在相关的杆框测试 (RFT) 中比男性更依赖视觉,我们假设女性会受到外部参照系更大的影响(即,交叉手偏差更大)。正如预测的那样,与我们的男性参与者相比,女性参与者在触觉 TOJ 上的偏差更大。我们还在手交叉和未交叉的情况下对这些参与者进行了 RFT 测试。双手交叉会增加 RFT 中框架的影响,女性比男性更为明显,这进一步突出了两种性别在适应参照系冲突方面的潜在差异。最后,检查这两个任务之间的关系显示出显著的相关性,较大的框架效应与较大的交叉手 TOJ 偏差相关,但这仅适用于男性。我们推测,在多感官处理和空间能力方面的性别特异性差异可能解释了为什么女性比男性更难以辨别交叉手姿势。