Balevi Ben
Private practitioner, affiliated with Faculty of Medicine, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Evid Based Dent. 2010;11(2):48-9. doi: 10.1038/sj.ebd.6400721.
Medline was used to search for relevant material for the review.
Systematic reviews and longitudinal prospective/ retrospective studies (randomised controlled trials, controlled clinical trials and cohort studies) were chosen that reported outcomes following treatment with implant-supported fixed partial denture prostheses (FPDP) with cantilever extensions, after a mean function time of at least 5 years. Two independent reviewers preformed screening and data abstraction.
Five-year survival and technical complication rates were extracted, which included: loss of prosthesis, loss of implants, complications with supra-construction (fractures or deformations of the framework or veneers, loss of retention and screw or abutment loosening) and marginal bone loss. Data from included studies were pooled and summarised as a weighted mean. Disagreement regarding data extraction was resolved by discussion and consensus.
Only three studies met the inclusion criteria for final analysis. Two of the studies had a prospective or retrospective case-control design, whereas the third was a prospective cohort study. The 5-year survival rate of cantilever FPDP varied between 89.9 and 92.7% (weighted mean, 91.9%), with implant fracture as the main cause for failure. The corresponding survival rate for FPDP without cantilever extensions was 95.3 to 96.2% (weighted mean, 95.8%). Technical complications related to the supra-construction in the three included studies were reported to occur at a frequency of 13-26% (weighted mean, 20.3%) for cantilever FPDP, compared with 0-12% (weighted mean, 9.7%) for noncantilever FPDP. The most common complications were minor porcelain fractures and bridge-screw loosening. For cantilever FPDP, the 5-year event-free survival rate varied between 66.7 and 79.2% (weighted mean, 71.7%) and between 83.1 and 96.3% (weighted mean, 85.9%) for noncantilever FPDP. No statistically significant differences were reported with regard to peri-implant bone-level change between the two prosthetic groups, either at the prosthesis or at the implant level.
Data on implant-supported FPDP with cantilever extensions are limited and therefore survival and complication rates should be interpreted with caution. The incorporation of cantilevers into implant-borne prostheses may be associated with a higher incidence of minor technical complications.
使用Medline检索相关文献以进行综述。
选取系统评价和纵向前瞻性/回顾性研究(随机对照试验、对照临床试验和队列研究),这些研究报告了悬臂延伸式种植体支持固定局部义齿修复体(FPDP)在平均功能时间至少5年后的治疗结果。两名独立评审员进行筛选和数据提取。
提取5年生存率和技术并发症发生率,包括:修复体脱落、种植体脱落、上部结构并发症(支架或贴面骨折或变形、固位丧失以及螺钉或基台松动)和边缘骨吸收。纳入研究的数据进行汇总并总结为加权平均值。数据提取方面的分歧通过讨论和达成共识来解决。
仅有三项研究符合最终分析的纳入标准。其中两项研究采用前瞻性或回顾性病例对照设计,而第三项是前瞻性队列研究。悬臂式FPDP的5年生存率在89.9%至92.7%之间(加权平均值为91.9%),种植体骨折是主要失败原因。无悬臂延伸的FPDP相应生存率为95.3%至96.2%(加权平均值为95.8%)。在纳入的三项研究中,悬臂式FPDP与上部结构相关的技术并发症发生率据报告为13% - 26%(加权平均值为20.3%),而非悬臂式FPDP为0% - 12%(加权平均值为9.7%)。最常见的并发症是轻微瓷折和桥螺钉松动。对于悬臂式FPDP,5年无事件生存率在66.7%至79.2%之间(加权平均值为71.7%),非悬臂式FPDP在83.1%至96.3%之间(加权平均值为85.9%)。在两个修复组之间,无论是在修复体还是种植体水平,种植体周围骨水平变化方面均未报告有统计学显著差异。
关于悬臂延伸式种植体支持FPDP的数据有限,因此生存率和并发症发生率的解释应谨慎。在种植体支持的修复体中采用悬臂可能与轻微技术并发症的较高发生率相关。