Donnelly J E, Pronk N P, Jacobsen D J, Pronk S J, Jakicic J M
Human Performance Lab, Kearney State College, NE.
Am J Clin Nutr. 1991 Jul;54(1):56-61. doi: 10.1093/ajcn/54.1.56.
Sixty-nine obese females received 90 d of a liquid diet providing 2184 kJ/d in clinical trials. Groups were diet only (C), diet plus endurance exercise (EE), diet plus weight training (WT), or diet plus endurance exercise and weight training (EEWT). Changes in body weight, percent fat, fat weight, and fat-free mass were not different between groups. Declines in resting metabolic rate (RMR) were approximately 7% to approximately 12% of baseline values with no differences among groups. A significant increase in work capacity (approximately 16%) was shown for EEWT. Strength index showed declines of approximately 6% for C and EE and gains of approximately 3% and approximately 10% for EEWT and WT, respectively. These clinical trials did not show advantages of any exercise regimen over diet alone for weight loss, body-composition changes, or declines in RMR. Improvements in work capacity were limited and strength improved in groups that participated in strength training.
在临床试验中,69名肥胖女性接受了为期90天的流食饮食,每天提供2184千焦能量。分组情况为:仅节食组(C)、节食加耐力运动组(EE)、节食加力量训练组(WT)、节食加耐力运动和力量训练组(EEWT)。各组之间体重、体脂百分比、脂肪重量和去脂体重的变化并无差异。静息代谢率(RMR)下降幅度约为基线值的7%至12%,各组之间无差异。EEWT组的工作能力显著提高(约16%)。力量指数方面,C组和EE组下降约6%,EEWT组和WT组分别增加约3%和约10%。这些临床试验并未表明,在减肥、身体成分变化或RMR下降方面,任何运动方案比单纯节食更具优势。工作能力的改善有限,而参与力量训练的组力量有所提高。