Mansell Jamie L, Tierney Ryan T, Higgins Michael, McDevitt Jane, Toone Nieka, Glutting Joseph
Department of Health, Physical Education & Recreation, Lincoln University, PA 19352, USA.
Brain Inj. 2010;24(9):1070-4. doi: 10.3109/02699052.2010.494589.
To evaluate the association between having a previously documented concussion and experiencing concussive signs and symptoms (S&S) following head impacts in collegiate athletes.
Two hundred and one college male football (n = 168) and female women's soccer (n = 33) athletes participated in this retrospective case-control study. Athletes completed a questionnaire and reported if they had been diagnosed with concussion and if they experienced concussive S&S following a head impact during a game or practice in the previous year.
Almost 60% (89 of 152) of non-concussed athletes reported experiencing S&S following head impacts in the previous year compared to 80% (39 of 49) of concussed athletes. The Phi coefficient (r = 0.196, p = 0.005) results indicated a significant association between previous history of concussion and the occurrence of S&S following a head impact.
A large percentage of non-concussed athletes are experiencing concussive S&S following head impacts during games and practices. Previously concussed athletes, however, report experiencing S&S more frequently following head impacts than their non-concussed counterparts. Although this study is subject to the limitations of a retrospective research design, these findings highlight the need for more diligent surveillance from clinicians, as many concussions are being missed.
评估大学运动员既往有脑震荡记录与头部撞击后出现脑震荡体征和症状(S&S)之间的关联。
201名大学男子足球运动员(n = 168)和女子足球运动员(n = 33)参与了这项回顾性病例对照研究。运动员完成了一份问卷,并报告他们是否被诊断为脑震荡,以及他们在上一年的比赛或训练中头部撞击后是否出现脑震荡S&S。
近60%(152人中的89人)未患脑震荡的运动员报告称在上一年头部撞击后出现了S&S,而患脑震荡的运动员中这一比例为80%(49人中的39人)。Phi系数(r = 0.196,p = 0.005)结果表明,既往脑震荡史与头部撞击后S&S的发生之间存在显著关联。
很大比例的未患脑震荡的运动员在比赛和训练中头部撞击后出现了脑震荡S&S。然而,既往患过脑震荡的运动员报告称,头部撞击后出现S&S的频率高于未患脑震荡的运动员。尽管这项研究受到回顾性研究设计的限制,但这些发现凸显了临床医生更勤勉监测的必要性,因为许多脑震荡都被漏诊了。