INSERM, U836, Equipe 6, B.P. 170, Grenoble Cedex 9 F-38042, France.
Med Phys. 2010 Jun;37(6):2445-56. doi: 10.1118/1.3327455.
Synchrotron stereotactic radiotherapy (SSRT) is a treatment that involves the targeting of high-Z elements into tumors followed by stereotactic irradiation with monochromatic x-rays from a synchrotron source, tuned at an optimal energy. The irradiation geometry, as well as the secondary particles generated at a higher yield by the medium energy x-rays on the high-Z atoms (characteristic x-rays, photoelectrons, and Auger electrons), produces a localized dose enhancement in the tumor. Iodine-enhanced SSRT with systemic injections of iodinated contrast agents has been successfully developed in the past six years in the team, and is currently being transferred to clinical trials. The purpose of this work is to study the impact on the SSRT treatment of the contrast agent type, the beam quality, the irradiation geometry, and the beam weighting for defining an optimized SSRT treatment plan.
Theoretical dosimetry was performed using the MCNPX particle transport code. The simulated geometry was an idealized phantom representing a human head. A virtual target was positioned in the central part of the phantom or off-centered by 4 cm. The authors investigated the dosimetric characteristics of SSRT for various contrast agents: Iodine, gadolinium, and gold; and for different beam qualities: Monochromatic x-ray beams from a synchrotron source (30-120 keV), polychromatic x-ray beams from an x-ray tube (80, 120, and 180 kVp), and a 6 MV x-ray beam from a linear accelerator. Three irradiation geometries were studied: One arc or three noncoplanar arcs dynamic arc therapy, and an irradiation with a finite number of beams. The resulting dose enhancements, beam profiles, and histograms dose volumes were compared for iodine-enhanced SSRT. An attempt to optimize the irradiation scheme by weighing the finite x-ray beams was performed. Finally, the optimization was studied on patient specific 3D CT data after contrast agent infusion.
It was demonstrated in this study that an 80 keV beam energy was a good compromise for treating human brain tumors with iodine-enhanced SSRT, resulting in a still high dose enhancement factor (about 2) and a superior bone sparing in comparison with lower energy x-rays. This beam could easily be produced at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility medical beamline. Moreover, there was a significant diminution of dose delivered to the bone when using monochromatic x-rays rather than polychromatic x-rays from a conventional tube. The data showed that iodine SSRT exhibits a superior sparing of brain healthy tissue in comparison to high energy treatment. The beam weighting optimization significantly improved the treatment plans for off-centered tumors, when compared to nonweighted irradiations.
This study demonstrated the feasibility of realistic clinical plans for low energy monochromatic x-rays contrast-enhanced radiotherapy, suitable for the first clinical trials on brain metastasis with a homogeneous iodine uptake.
同步辐射立体定向放疗(SSRT)是一种治疗方法,涉及将高 Z 元素靶向肿瘤,然后用同步辐射源产生的单色 X 射线进行立体定向照射,其能量调谐至最佳。照射几何形状以及中能 X 射线在高 Z 原子(特征 X 射线、光电子和俄歇电子)上产生的更高产率的次级粒子,在肿瘤中产生局部剂量增强。过去六年,团队成功开发了碘增强的 SSRT 并进行了全身注射碘造影剂,目前正在转移到临床试验中。这项工作的目的是研究造影剂类型、束质量、照射几何形状和束权重对 SSRT 治疗计划的优化的影响。
使用 MCNPX 粒子输运代码进行理论剂量学研究。模拟几何形状是代表人体头部的理想化模型。在模型的中央部分或中心偏移 4 厘米处定位虚拟目标。作者研究了不同造影剂的 SSRT 剂量学特性:碘、钆和金;以及不同的束质量:来自同步辐射源的单色 X 射线束(30-120keV)、来自 X 射线管的多色 X 射线束(80、120 和 180kVp)和来自线性加速器的 6MV X 射线束。研究了三种照射几何形状:一个弧形或三个非共面弧形动态弧形治疗,以及用有限数量的射线照射。比较了碘增强 SSRT 的剂量增强、束轮廓和剂量体积直方图。尝试通过加权有限 X 射线束来优化照射方案。最后,在对比剂输注后的患者特定 3DCT 数据上进行了优化研究。
本研究表明,80keV 的束能量是用碘增强 SSRT 治疗人脑肿瘤的一个很好的折衷方案,与低能 X 射线相比,仍能产生较高的剂量增强因子(约 2)和更好的骨保护。这种束很容易在欧洲同步辐射设施的医疗束线上产生。此外,与传统管中的多色 X 射线相比,使用单色 X 射线会显著减少对骨骼的剂量。数据表明,与高能治疗相比,碘 SSRT 可显著减少对大脑健康组织的剂量。与非加权照射相比,束权重优化显著改善了偏心肿瘤的治疗计划。
本研究证明了适用于具有均匀碘摄取的脑转移首次临床试验的低能单色 X 射线对比增强放疗的现实临床计划的可行性。