Division of Pulmonary, Allergy, Critical Care and Sleep Medicine, Center for Critical Care, Department of Internal Medicine, The Ohio State University Medical Center, Columbus, OH 43210, USA.
J Crit Care. 2010 Dec;25(4):658.e7-15. doi: 10.1016/j.jcrc.2010.04.010. Epub 2010 Jun 19.
We sought to evaluate factors associated with choices about provided care for patients with septic shock, including the use of drotrecogin α (activated) (DAA).
We administered a mail-based survey to a random sample of intensivists. Study vignettes presented patients with septic shock with identical severity of illness scores but different ages, body mass indices, and comorbidities. Respondents estimated outcomes and selected care beyond standardized initial care (eg, antibiotics) for each hypothetical patient.
For most vignettes (99.1%), respondents added care, most commonly low tidal volume ventilation (87.6%) and enteral nutrition (73.3%). Choosing to administer DAA was not associated with predictions about mortality or bleeding. Vignettes with early-stage lung cancer were less likely to receive DAA. Time since medical school graduation was also associated with lower odds of selecting DAA. Most respondents (52.6%) chose identical care for all 4 completed vignettes.
There was wide variability in the therapeutic choices of respondents. The use of DAA was not associated with perceived risk of mortality or bleeding, as recommended by consensus guidelines. Physicians appear to base treatment decisions in septic shock on a consistent pattern of practice rather than estimates of patient outcome.
我们旨在评估与脓毒性休克患者所接受治疗选择相关的因素,包括使用重组人活化蛋白 C(Drotrecogin α(activated),DAA)。
我们向随机抽取的重症监护医师发送了一份基于邮件的调查问卷。研究病例以相同严重程度的疾病评分呈现患有脓毒性休克的患者,但具有不同的年龄、体重指数和合并症。受访者为每位假设患者评估预后并选择标准初始治疗(如抗生素)以外的治疗方案。
对于大多数病例(99.1%),受访者选择了额外的治疗方案,最常见的是小潮气量通气(87.6%)和肠内营养(73.3%)。选择使用 DAA 与对死亡率或出血的预测无关。伴有早期肺癌的病例接受 DAA 的可能性较小。从医学院毕业的时间也与选择 DAA 的可能性呈负相关。大多数受访者(52.6%)选择了所有 4 个完成病例的相同治疗方案。
受访者的治疗选择存在很大差异。DAA 的使用与共识指南建议的死亡率或出血风险无关。医生似乎根据一贯的实践模式而不是对患者预后的估计来做出脓毒性休克的治疗决策。